r/ATLA Mar 18 '25

Discussion Yeah why did she become one anyway

Post image
7.8k Upvotes

315 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1.2k

u/Flameball202 Mar 18 '25

Yeah, they do live about half a world away from each other, and with Korra finishing her training at the pole Katara has only just gotten free time to come and visit, of course the five year old doesn't recognise her, she probably hasn't been back the last few years, but the older kids do because of course she visited occasionally

414

u/Koolco Mar 18 '25

To be fair “half a world away” in atla is like, a day of flying.

589

u/ValeWho Mar 18 '25

In our world it is also a day of flying, but if you ask someone whose family lives halfway round the world how often they see each other it's probably not that often

-12

u/Koolco Mar 18 '25

Yea but, they’re airbenders, they fly everywhere already. Its also pretty easy to argue at the very least that the planet is much smaller, in atla the gang was flying all over the place, in korra flying basically anywhere takes less than a day, and even by boat republic city to the south pole is only like, a nights boat ride.

77

u/ValeWho Mar 18 '25

Would you like to spend 12+hours on a bison with 4 children under the age of 12? There is a reason the show was mostly set when they landed somewhere. The time flying was probably very boring.

25

u/DrainianDream Mar 18 '25

Also unlike long car rides, the stakes of a restless child not being able to sit still goes from “mildly annoying” to “potentially falling out of the sky”

4

u/Consistent_Oil3428 Mar 18 '25

Dude…airbenders are nomads, they DO spend 12+ hours on a bison with 4 children, thats the WHOLE PREMISE of being a nomad

9

u/Mountain-Resource656 Mar 18 '25

To be fair, airbenders are also all about not having strong family ties. Like, all airbenders are, in essence, orphans. They leave their children at temples to be raised communally and then go on their way

So as a baseline, of course they wouldn’t see much need to go see Katara

Of course, on the other hand, although technically these kids were raised not just communally, but by the entire air nomad culture that existed at that point, they were also a very normal, close-knit family just like any other. Buuut on the third hand, that does also indicate a drift away from standard air nomad practices- like nomadism. Indeed, we see that they don’t actually appear to be nomads at this point. They even dropped that from their name in favor of “nation,” didn’t they?

10

u/100Fowers Mar 18 '25

The airbenders were nomads.

It kind of seems Tenzin spends most of his day at the monetary or the office. Plus he has a pregnant and sedentary wife

1

u/Digit00l Mar 19 '25

Technically they kept the children at the temples for the most part

0

u/Koolco Mar 18 '25

I mean, yea. Summer roadtrips with a stuffed car is like, an entire trope.

10

u/Rabbulion Mar 18 '25

Yeah, but all the things that happen except the occasional fight (which while entertaining for a viewer is unlikely to be desirable for those involved) happen when they stop somewhere.

If you wanna watch the world from above for hours, sit and watch the Netflix screensaver

9

u/DementedJ23 Mar 18 '25

Pema is pregnant all the time. constant travel sucks even when you aren't pregnant... but thentrabel times are so wonky that it cuts both ways, it seemed like getting anywhere took forever fighting kuvira, and everyone was basically using contemporary travel methods that don't need to eat or sleep, then. The truth is everyone moved like in star wars, at the speed of plot. And plot required separated families.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '25

That would make tenzin the one who is choosing not to visit his mother.

3

u/IJustWantADragon21 Mar 18 '25

Good point. He has the bison! He could have made the trip sometime in the last 4-5 years!