r/ATLA Mar 18 '25

Discussion Yeah why did she become one anyway

Post image
7.8k Upvotes

315 comments sorted by

View all comments

2.5k

u/MrBKainXTR Mar 18 '25

I think its a stretch to assume that Katara has never met any of her three grandchildren before simply because the five year old doesn't recognize her.

140

u/MastadonWarlord Mar 18 '25

When I watched that scene, I never got the feeling that Katara never met them either. I mean, Pema was comfortable enough to complain that she wanted a non bender like her. If Katar had never met the kids, she definitely would have seen Pema maybe once before?

I always took it as Meelo hadn't seen her since he was a baby. Maybe they could have said "it so good to see all of you, again." But she didn't say,"It's so good to meet all of you. " I just think people aren't paying attention, don't understand actual interactions, or both.

8

u/geek_of_nature Mar 19 '25

Also Jinora and Ikki act familiar with her, so it's just likely it's been a couple years since they've seen her, where Meelo just doesn't remember the last time.

2

u/LynJo1204 Mar 19 '25

Right. Remembering people comes with either age or consistency and he's too young to remember her if she hasn't been been around regularly.