Throwaway account. Might be long, sorry.
I (M41) been with my gf (F36) for just over two years. In those two years we've learned a lot about each other and grew significantly together. We both have had our share of bad relationships, I myself had just gotten out of a toxic 16 year marriage.
The one thing we promised each other early in the relationship is to be as open and honest about everything as we can. Through several conversations we've discovered a lot of our problems in the past have stemmed from this and we don't want them to repeat. For the most part I feel we've done a pretty decent job at this. We've gotten each other to open up about things that were bothering us and we worked them out. In the end they turned out to be not as bad as we thought they'd be and through that we learned a little more, and loved and appreciated each other a lot more.
As I'm typing this I'm realizing the answer to my own question is to just address the issue and talk about it. But here's my hang up, and I've been stewing over this for a while now. This issue is porn. A lot of relationships have had major issues with porn. A big part of the issues with my last marriage was that I was being accused of being addicted to porn. I'm not. But that's not what we're here for...
We've had this discussion. We are both comfortable with each other occasionally watching it, we've even watched it together several times, awkwardly, and decided it's best to just keep it a private thing. We've talked about what we're into, what excites us and gets us going. We've dived into some of the weirder stuff and had a few good laughs at it. We go to the "adult" shops and buy toys, lubes, even those questionable enhancement pills just for fun.
The long and short (heh) of it is that we're pretty comfortable with each other, both sexually and of course normally. We consider each other our best friend. I've never had a relationship where I've been more open or comfortable with everything before, it's bizarre how I've gone so long and have never felt the way I do now.
I hope that give a good idea of our relationship, now onto the issue. The other day we were lying in bed, we had just woken up from a fun night before and we're recapping some of the details. One of the topics was funny halloween costumes. We start looking at some stuff on Amazon on her phone, and she then gets up to go use the bathroom. Now I know what you're thinking and no we don't snoop through each other's phones, we both know each other's passwords and let the other have full access to them whenever. We have nothing to hide.
BUT! I remember having this costume conversation before so I go to pull up some webpages we've already checked out. I open up the history and start scrolling down pretty fast. Of course I see the porn pages but think nothing of them as I try to find what I'm trying to find.
Once I find it I see a few other hits nearby but this time actually see what it says: cuck
Yep the OTHER c-word. Now again I don't think to much of this until I start scrolling back up and start seeing it more and more only this time with other searches mixed in: interracial, BBC, cheating wife that kind of stuff. And it's A LOT. Like every day a lot.
Now back when we first got together and were discussing things like this and our history of relationships, I confided in her that I've been cheated on a few times and she knows that I have some serious issues with it. She also confided in me that she had cheated on her partner as well so I know she has a history of it. Also this scenario never came up when we spoke about our porn likes.
So now my thought process is my girlfriend, whom I had the best experience with, gets off on idea of me watching her cheat on me...
This of course only open the floodgates to other thoughts of not being good enough, is this what she really wants, and worst of all, has this happened?
The thing that gets me is that this was so hidden. We've tried so hard to keep open lines of communication. We've made it a priority to be open and honest with each other and we know how each other feels about certain things. She's made comments that just seeing me interact with other women, even in total innocence, makes her jealous and her thinking of being with anyone else makes her feel sick. Now whether that's true or not, the meaning behind it only enhances my feeling over the whole issue.
So, AIO? Or do I just need to chill out and let freaks freak?
Edit: While I may not respond, I am reading and appreciate everyone's replies. Thanks for everyone's insight.