r/AoSLore 4d ago

Question Ancestor Gods

Do we know how the dwarven Ancestor Gods came about? I know they were all originally mortals but has it ever been explained how Grimnir or Valaya were elevated to become gods?

28 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

15

u/MrS0bek Idoneth Deepkin 4d ago

I can only speak for WFB in this regard as I do not now how AoS handles them. But dwarfs had an ancestor cult where all the ancestors of your clan were venerated. In this sense any dead dwarf is an ancestor god.

Of course the proper title is primarily used for Grugni and Grimnir, their wife Valaya, and their first gen children. Valaya is the central figure as all dawi claim descendants from here. Otherwise this lineage is important. E.g. only descendants of Grugni can become runesmiths.

Now how did they achieve godhood? WFBs prehistory is vague on purpose. IIRC it is only mentioned that Grugni, Grimnir and Valaya were the first dwarfs to awake. But dwarfs were creations of the Old Ones. And thus its easy to think that the Old Ones either created the Ancestor Gods directly, or that they picked these three from the primitive dwarfen species and uplifted them. Essentially turning them into dwarfen primarchs. It helps that the ancestor gods learned a lot in a magical place, the glittering realm, IIRC.

Still in WFB veneration and worship are powerful forces and can form gods or elevate one to godhood. All gods are essentially collective manifestations of mortals beliefs and values. E.g. Sigmar attained godhood through his worship and veneration. And given how strong dwarfen ancestor worship is, the ancestor gods who were worshipped by every dwarf could rise from Old One enhanced dawi to full deities.

But this is WFB fluff. How it behaves in AoS I dunno. Beacuse the End Times, which bridge the two, is a devasty for WFB Fans, and strongly ignored and retconned by AoS. E.g. as per End Times lore Valaya should be dead and consumed by Nagash IIRC. But in the new AoS fluff she lead an army against Hashut.

14

u/Fyraltari Helsmiths of Hashut 4d ago

Grugni, Grimnir and Valaya were the first dwarfs to awake.

And Gazul, everyone always forget Gazul.

9

u/MrS0bek Idoneth Deepkin 4d ago

True. For some reading I always think he was Grimnirs son or something like that. But he is the off one with no known offspring aside from maybe Skarvor

10

u/Fyraltari Helsmiths of Hashut 4d ago

It's because despite being the brother of the major ancestor, he's a minor one alongside his nephews. Which makes little sense since he's a death god.

5

u/MrS0bek Idoneth Deepkin 4d ago

True Gazul is a bit bizarre.

I probably think of him being a son as he started the ancestors veneration and invented funeral rites. It makes more sense IMO that a son or grandson does this to venerate their ancestors, than someone from the first generation who doesn't have anyone to rever or bury.

Basicly if a child or grandchild invents this stuff is honest veneration or homage. But if someone of the first gen does it it comes off as a bit arrogant. "Listen we are important. So you better worship us after our demise!"

3

u/Fyraltari Helsmiths of Hashut 4d ago

He might have buried his siblings, no?

5

u/MrS0bek Idoneth Deepkin 4d ago

He might, though what did he do/invent until that time?

Valaya: Founds various holds, establishes dwarfen laws, brewing, and civilization

Grugni: Establishes the practice of living underground, mines and smithing

Grimnir: Establishes dwarfen warrior culture and protects his kin from hostile dangers and monsters

Gazul: Can someone of you die already? Please?

3

u/Fyraltari Helsmiths of Hashut 4d ago

Prophecy, maybe?

Also it's entirely likely that some of the second or third generation dwarfs predeceased the first. Or might just have helped around, I don't know.

8

u/posixthreads Slaves to Darkness 4d ago

How it behaves in AoS I dunno.

It works the same way, with Kragnos being a prime example here.

4

u/KacSzu Stormcast Eternals 4d ago

Grugni and Grimnir, their wife Valaya,

their wife? I'm overthinking it, right?

17

u/MrS0bek Idoneth Deepkin 4d ago edited 4d ago

Nope both married the same women. Polyandry, multiple husbands. Isn't that weird overall. Dwarfs were supposed to have less females than males for example. So it is a practical solution. Keep in mind that dwarfs are not humans but have a different value system and psychology too.

Indeed womenfolk is held in high regard. Even if its always male dwarfs doing stuff in the fluff, it is likley that dwarfen queens were the true power of a hold.

Also in RL marriage is basicly a result of inheritance laws and what is and Isn't acceptable in marriage varies a lot based on social customs. See e.g. in-law widow marriages even mentioned in the bible. Or how males being unfaithful is much less important than females. Because any outside family bastard isn't able to inherit anyhow, but the baby is a financial burden for the mothers family and/or her husband. Basicly it is not the mans problem if they whore around. Even today we may glorify men for having multiple partners but disgrace women doing the same, as an artefacts of such customs

And IIRC around Tibet there was a law that all males of a family inherited an equal share of farmland. But then farmland quickly became to small to support anyone. So polyandry was introduced wherein all brothers would marry the same wife, so that no more land would be split over the generations.

7

u/sageking14 Lord Audacious 4d ago

Valaya was also their sister.

6

u/Fyraltari Helsmiths of Hashut 4d ago

Just gods being gods.

3

u/Axe1_the_Minerva_fan Helsmiths of Hashut 4d ago

Double teaming with your brother do be fun sometimes

2

u/TioMorteLoko Flesh-Eater Courts 2d ago

Whf Gods do practice a lot of polyamory. 

Taal and Rhya are noted in particular for have taken many lovers outside of their marriage with each others consent for the sake of creating new gods and divine beings.

4

u/Stuniverse10 3d ago

Do you think it's possible that Grimnir the God is not the same as Grimnir the mortal?

With the way belief works in warhammer, the gods could, in theory, just be memories or ideas of their ancestors manifesting within the Aether?

5

u/MrS0bek Idoneth Deepkin 3d ago

That is something I cannot answer. Is it possible? I'd say yes. But also that Grimnirs own soul was the initial ingridient upon which stuff was added. Or something else entirely. With the aether everything may be possible to an extend or the other

6

u/Illustrious-Wrap-776 4d ago

Back in the pre-history of Warhammer Fantasy, the first of the Ancestor Gods were the first Dwarfs to be created or uplifted by the Old Ones, most likely already a cut above mortal Dwarfs. Some of their children also inherited this, but not all of them (maybe).

The Ancestor worship most likely further boosted their strength, though just with Nagash, at what point it's fair to call them Gods could be a topic of lengthy debates on its own (though more in the always of how many centuries after they retreated from mortal affairs sense).

Over time, they retreated from mortal affairs, like Grimnir going north to stem the then unending tide of Daemons coming from the broken warp gate.

Snorri Whitebeard is the oldest son of Grungni and Valaya, but usually not counted among the Ancestor Gods, instead becoming the first High King after the Ancestor Gods departed. He was good friends with Malerion, to the point that the Elf was at his deathbed and swore an oath to defend the friendship the two of them established between Dwarfs and Elves. It's basically confirmed that Malerion breaking that oath brought him back as Grombrindal, who could be counted as an Ancestor God, but he still dies as a mortal would before he ascended.

Valaya seems to have sealed herself in a vault, which is breached during the End Times, allowing Nagash to drain her of her magic (to me, it always read as if he left her severely weakened but alive, others interpret it as her being dead).

Also during the End Times, Gotrek Gurnisson takes the place of Grimnir, fighting the hordes of Daemons at their source for eternity, so Grimnir can rejoin the other Ancestor Gods.

Now for AoS, there are some passages that indicate that the Ancestor Gods and the surviving Dawrfs literally burrier themselves into the Mortal Realms. Since the Ancestor Gods most likely fully ascended very early in the WHFB timeline, they are obviously already Gods when they show up in the Mortal Realms.