r/BattleForDreamIsland • u/abd12R4llah Pen • Jul 27 '25
Question Be Honest Did Yall Also Think This Was Pencil Rejecting Ones Offer At First
129
u/Educational_Bill8901 Woody Jul 28 '25
Yes,Definitely, Absolutely
34
u/Key-Astronaut1883 Grassy Jul 28 '25
Is that a gravity falls reference I see?
6
u/VisibleConfusion12 Match Jul 28 '25
my ex wife still misses me
5
u/CrazyPotatooooooooo Golf Ball Jul 28 '25
BUT HER AIM IS GETTING BETTER
3
2
u/South_Introduction94 Saw Jul 28 '25
"REALITY IS AN ILLUSION, THE UNIVERSE IS A HOLOGRAM, BUY GOLD, BYE!!"
2
14
u/cynder_blockz Snowball Jul 28 '25
woody mention 😻😻😻
5
u/Lukas_Iles Ruby Jul 28 '25
Rusty coin pfp
2
116
u/Yellowish2 Blocky Jul 28 '25
My cheers turned into abysmal disappointment
34
u/GullibleChef667 Donut Jul 28 '25
Same! I thought that she may have actually become a good character again for a second.
13
u/Zoey_tdroti One Jul 28 '25
My disappointment turned into cheers (One couldn't have been defeated this easily let's be real)
63
u/Fortniteballs2996 Blocky Jul 28 '25
yeah I thought she was gonna fight her or sum shit
7
u/PensionDeep1680 Bracelety Jul 28 '25
i see what you did there;)
16
u/InformationLost5910 Pillow Jul 28 '25
i dont see what they did there
5
u/Fourth_of_ju-lier87 Dora Jul 28 '25
They said "or SUM shit"
8
u/InformationLost5910 Pillow Jul 28 '25
that wasnt a joke lmao 😂its a common slang intentional misspelling
2
2
37
u/GanacheArtistic1983 Tennis Ball Jul 28 '25
Yes I was so confused I thought pencil was attacking her
23
u/LogicalAd6394 Fanny Jul 28 '25
I believe that Pencil rejected One's offer and blasted One; expecting the same result with Four
39
u/OhGodWhyyy456 Leafy Jul 28 '25
Who didn’t?
13
16
u/James_Pavell7 Evil Leafy Jul 28 '25
Yes until I remembered the leaks that my stupid eyes refused to turn away from
14
u/Sacsacher Tennis Ball Jul 28 '25
I liked the ambiguity, a real moment that makes you lean in closer to watch
16
u/Speedy-E-2975 Tennis Ball Jul 28 '25
I watched at the meet up, so everyone was screaming at the top of their lungs and I couldn’t hear what she said after.
3
u/RepresentativeEmu941 Book Jul 28 '25
werent there captions o-o
2
u/Speedy-E-2975 Tennis Ball Jul 28 '25
It was very overwhelming. Especially with the people behind me screaming violent death threats over a fictional pencil and number the whole time.
1
11
7
7
u/Spec1alF0x Taco Jul 28 '25
True! I didnt think it was gonna work and I was actually mad happy for a second
4
u/Randomfrickinhuman Bottle Jul 28 '25
yeah this scene was confusing couldnt they just have made pencil directly fight her that woulda been fun
3
5
3
2
2
2
2
u/MilWeas Jul 28 '25
I got so excited I thought everything could go back to normal but then it was just pure panic and shock ._.
2
2
2
1
1
1
1
u/CobaltRebelionXyz Nonexisty Jul 28 '25
Me: "Yes, yes, YES!"
Also me: "To the surprise of absolutely nobody."
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Gabriels_Adventure Announcer Jul 28 '25
I’m pretty sure that was the intention. That it initially seemed like Pencil was fighting back only for it to turn out she was agreeing.
1
u/Timely-Economist-731 Gelatin Jul 28 '25
Yes and my smile immediately disappeared after I saw she didn't.. but I'm excited to see what will happen in the future episodes.
1
u/Able_Feeling_7854 Four Jul 28 '25
I absolutely did thought she rejected the deal. That is, until my second watch when dissected the dialogue again.
1
1
1
u/Personal_Weakness_26 Nonexisty Jul 28 '25
I'm pretty sure that's what was supposed to happen, we were supposed to think Pencil just merc'd One
1
1
u/Born_Recognition_718 Coiny Jul 28 '25
I knew something was up. I didn’t think they would just kill off one, the main antagonist, right in the middle of the series out of nowhere
1
u/Suspicious_City5316 Fries Jul 28 '25
I was confused asf I thought One was about to die or somethin
1
1
1
u/Expired-Lemonz Jul 28 '25
I really did wish this was Pencil attacking 1, but she is really desperate to have her alliance back so I understand why this didnt happen.
1
1
u/orengjoos Nickel Jul 28 '25
Yea. They probably could have made this look different. Like, maybe a handshake or something
1
1
1
1
u/reddemp Golf Ball Jul 28 '25
I started jumping and cheering and dancing and allat when I thought this, then I saw One alive and I started crying and scolding pencil
1
u/MemerMonokuma Fries Jul 28 '25
Considering how crazy the episode was, I thought One was gonna die or something
1
u/only_l0ttie Fanny Jul 28 '25
Yep 😭😭 i started cheering but then my friend (who had already seen it) told me cheering was NOT the right reaction here 😔
1
1
u/Happy_man-Fix9375 Income Tax Return Document Jul 28 '25
They made everyone scream YEAHHHHHH! to WHYYYYYYYYYY!
1
u/CuttyWutty Rocky Jul 28 '25
As others said she may have accidentally gave the powers to one given how she looks a little surprised by her limbs no longer glowing, especially given how we can see there are less dramatic ways to give power seeing how Grassy, Tennis Ball, and Donut just had to agree to it, but I think if Pencil really wanted to she would have been able to hurt/kill One since we just saw her beat up Four here, I think it was just the show using misdirection for the previously mentioned dramatic effect
1
1
1
1
1
u/thefroakian Jul 28 '25
Yes definitely everyone did, but you can't be and at pencil, pencil doesn't even know who one is.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Possible_Pineapple20 Jul 28 '25
Yes I was thinking (and hoping) that this scene was them killing one off😭
1
u/lance_the_fatass Pin Jul 28 '25
It kinda seems like they deliberately wanted us to think that with the way it was animated
1
1
u/KuzcoWiTheGroovesco Jul 28 '25
nope
I remembered Fanny saying "IT BURNS" when she got Two's power, and I knew there was no way Pencil would decline the offer in her current state
1
1
u/TheBiggestWoodyFan Jul 28 '25
I’ve been talking to myself abt this since the episode came out
Pencil probably thought it was too good to be true so she tries killing one with her newly obtained powers
Then after she realises one didn’t die, pencil tries to make it out as if she was giving one her powers which is why she talks about one giving pencil her end of the deal.
Now depending on whether one believed pencil or not she either sent her to the past or killed her
1
1
u/Sea_Cardiologist9570 Lightning Jul 28 '25
Yes, the next scene convinced me that One knows what their trying to do or she's just being a lunatic (haha... luna? Pun.) from being in the moon for Four knows how long.
1
u/Chemical-Class6453 Jul 28 '25
Dude, I don’t know how to make this clearer.
I WISH! I WIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII-SSSSSSSSHHHHHH
1
1
u/BingusZodiacYT Price Tag Jul 28 '25
I was looping and partying to that scene, but then I watched pass and saw One with the powers I shouted “Oh no.”
1
1
1
1
1
u/staramelle_ Pin Jul 30 '25
Yeah, I originally thought that she was murdering One, but seeing how things ended up I believe that she was actually accepting the offer. Considering that at the start of the ep, Fanny did say that when she was getting a bit of Two's power that it "burned", so delivering the entirety of two algebralien's powers at once could be violent. And that's just a theory...
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/The_Error_family_ 22d ago
BROOOO I SWEAR WHEN SHE I SHOT ONE. I THOUGHT HE WOULD HAVE REFUSED. I mean... unfortunately it makes sense that he accepted, BUT HOW COOL WOULD IT HAVE BEEN IF HE HAD NOT.
1
u/imtoogayformyself Ruby 21d ago
NOT AT ALL! No, no, no no, Pencil was just transferring our payment over to me. She would NEVER disobey our agreement. because i wouldn't allow that
1
1
u/Loose_Exchange_7074 Black Hole 19d ago
yes. And I'm quite surprised to find out that's not what happened, lol
312
u/Moviemin Tune Jul 27 '25
I still think she was trying to kill her, but she accidently gave the power to one