r/CharacterRant • u/PhoemixFox2728 • Jul 18 '25
General Fuck Short King Wolverine, I want Short King Batman: A Ninja fan/writer/critic's analysis on the portrayal of ninjutsu among western characters and how height can affect story telling
TLDR; this isnt a post actually about Batman and especially not wolverine, instead it's about how there aren't enough short fighters and main characters/protagonists throughout media, how canonically and metacontextually ninja-inspired characters tend to rarely if ever truly be ninja or satisfy my yearning for ninjutsu.
With that said, I believe the best place to start is where my love of ninjas began: the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, their 87 and original live action incarnations specifically, which might sound like the punchline to a bad joke. How could these version of the characters, the least ninja inspire a love of ninjutsu? Well the answer to that is that they technically didn't, I just fell in love with the TMNT franchise as a little kid which meant any and every TMNT thing and show I could get my grubby hands on(yes even next mutation) I hungrily and happily watched until 2012, probably a month or two before my 7th birthday when I would get the best gift I could hope for that year, a brand new incarnation of my favorite foursome. So it is in 2012 where my love for ninjas began and this makes a bit more sense, no? While still not as Ninjas as 2003, or you know actual Ninja characters, TMNT 2012 is where many young boys like myself at the time fell in love with the idea of ancient, mystic, smart, yet strong and extremely skilled super duper powerful warriors. And I was hooked, from a TMNT obsession I quickly grew and developed an obsession with ninjutsu, which wasn't helped by discovering the Gaijin Goomba a year later, beginning my true ninja fandom. See this love for ninjas was no longer remotely attached to my four favorite turtles, I liked those characters because of their personalities and adventures, but as a true ninja nerd at this point and from then on they never really satisfied me.
Hell, when I went back and watched the extremely ninja iteration of the turtles from 2003 I was still not satisfied by the display of ninjutsu even though the show was good, same could be said for Rise, and Mutant Mayhem all good things and all good turtles media, but hardly a very fulfilling Ninja. Even Japanese versions of Ninja characters didn't quite scratch that itch as Naruto was a just alright shounen in my book, so I kept on consuming media, criticizing some of it, you know the drill until I decided enough of this pussy footing and waiting around. Why don't I just make a Ninja character of my own? I have a decade of ninja fanaticism under my belt, that many years of expertise, I had just recently watched Batman 2022, and I was researching dozens of fighting styles and whatnot. So, there I was about to make my own ninja character when I decided hey why not consume a bunch of batman projects and media to see if I can't get some hot nasty inspiration for this guy and that's where/when I do my Batman 2004 review, you get the idea I was once more scorned by a supposedly ninja character except this time I was a bit more fed up than usual. I mean Batman is supposed to be THE icon of western Ninjutsu, we literally have a whole squad of turtles who call themselves ninjas explicitly, trained by ninjas on screen, and whose main enemy is a ninja who leads a ninja clan, so why is it that he particularly offended me?
Batman is too damned tall and big to be a ninja, have you seen takes on Batman like the Absolute universe where the fucker is even fucking bigger yet still bothers to wear Black as if it is hiding anything. This is a major problem for the TMNT and their enemies too to be honest, all of these characters get way too big, the things they wear while effective for sneaking around today aren't historically accurate which means anytime these characters go to the past and fight ninjas, they are fighting bad Ninjas who are wearing Black in what should be a navy/dark blue sky. A lot of these characters use some absolutely terrible Ninja weapons like fucking Chinese glaives or whatever, those big fuck you swords, you know katanas already shouldn't technically be a part of a ninja's armory, but then Rise Leo uses a fucking nodachi. EVEN A LOT OF SAMURAI DIDNT USE NODACHI!!! Do you know how big you would have to be to use a nodachi like a regular katana or remotely efficiently enough to be remotely ninja and sneaky with it? Approximately 8 feet tall, and you might think that's ridiculous. However, Japanese people on average are shorter than 6 feet tall, especially in ancient times when the nodachi originated. It should only take one or two more feet to use one like a katana, right? WRONG! What people who don't know a lot about the nodachi fail to consider is its weight and the massive curve/bend in it, which makes using it for an unintended purpose practically fucking impossible.
Nunchucks are frequently listed as ninja weapons and whatnot, but as far as I can tell there is very little historical truth or precedent to this, it's just a trope and idea created/popularized by the TMNT, same kind of goes for sai as far as I can tell and know these two weapons are just popular, compact, martial arts weapons. While there certainly were Ninja who probably did use they, they aren't as represented among ninja ranks as you might want to believe, which is why I prefer when raph uses tonfas, tonfas are also underrated. Anyways, back to batman he particularly cheeses me off because this is a character that is so extremely well written and in terms of ninjutsu his implementation of tech makes him a perfect ninja, but this man has no tool kit outside of his utility tools and whatnot, sure he and especially the modern TMNT have been good about using good ninja claws(aka tiger claws) that assist them in climbing and shit, using gauntlets occasionally, but god I am starting to get sick of how these guys over rely on shurrikens for their ranges option. I get it, characters like Batman have to use shurrikens in order to stand out as a ninja and he's not allowed to use bows because other characters have that as their entire gimmick and kit, but jesus christ if I see another forced batman shuriken instead of a regular old, perfectly ninja batarang I will lose it. And yes while Ninja didn't use boomerangs, if they could make ones as effective and powerful as the ones that Batman is known for they would just use them, likely over shurikens due to how easy it is to collect them. I also just think Batarangs make more sense for batman's character, shurikens, and kunai(which are woefully underrepresented among ALL western ninjas) are deadly weapons even if you throw them in places that are nonlethal because if some dumbass pulls them out they just cooked themselves.
Now, while we're back to Batman I get it okay, I know why this character cant be and wont ever be portrayed as short, he's kind of famous for having kid/teen side kicks, he's one of the most popular super heroes, so many of his villains are the average American height and even taller some times, and Superman one of the other DC characters who Batman is frequently compared to in and out of canon is 6 ft tall and sometimes even taller, isn't Henry Cavil like 6'3, he's like a head taller than Michael keaton I think. So yeah it's a pipe dream and hyper specific request to demand Batman be short, DareDevil less so. I genuinely, sincerely believe DareDevil to be the best western Ninja character for one extremely simple reason, that man's pain tolerance, and the amount of suffering he endures both in and out of the mask are sometimes leagues above his contemporaries. Batman, the turtles, so many other ninja can be broken and it makes sense IRL the whole point of Ninjutsu tactics and whatnot is the complete opposite of being one man armies, as a Ninja you are supposed to work with a four person Squad(mainly) and you are supposed to avoid fights. Even the attention of one Samurai in a prolonged fight is end game for a ninja, I mean the point of short, easily transportable weapons is to be great assassins and sneak fighters which ninjas are, but the second you put them in a head to head fight against even a single combatant, those martal arts/ninja weapons we were talking about earlier lose their advantage, so when you give them oodles and oodles of opponents they slowly lose that advantage.
Which is why I like DareDevil, he is a sadiomasochist a man who is equal parts happy and wanting to drag himself over hot coals, broken glass, and freshly squeezed lemon juice just so he can deal out some punishment and save people and a character who likes and intelligently tackles an army of goons. Compare his tactics to Batman and the turtles and very swiftly you'll see Batman and the turtles have the absolutely massive advantage of being super humans basically. Batman and the turtles are frequently, practically bulletproof, with one swing the turtles can send one guy flying into a dozen other guys, and with all of his tech and gear batman can essentially do the exact same thing even if he isn't as strong as the turtles sometimes. DareDevil even though if I remember correctly, he is considered a mutate, as in the same thing or a similar thing to the Fantastic Four and Spider-Man, so at the very least he is peak human which as we can see with Batman that's a title that can get stretched pretty far, but in the sole piece of Daredevil media I've consumed: his tv show he's barely peak human, he is on the very low and shallow side of the peak human spectrum. So for DareDevil to clear a hallway of dickheads it takes him a good five minutes or so, whereas for Batman and the Turltles we would just skip the fight and see them instantly bust through the door on the other side, which let me say here not a bad thing. It might sound like I am shitting on Batman and the turles, but I love these guys especially the TMNT, I just find it a little annoying as a ninja guy. Anyhow, yeah Marvel make A DareDevil a short king, just for an elseworld story, or in the Ultimate universe or something, please I think this character who already has so many hurdles to overcome and deal with whenever he wears the mask so it would be even cooler and more effective if he was a short king who had an even harder time to stand toe to toe with the likes of Wilson Fisk and his other villains.
Actually fuck it, more short kings in action media in general and no Ted "Mission Impossible" Cruise does not count because I've never watched those movies and I don't think many people know how short Ted Cruise is. Anyways, if you've read this far and now confidently think I am insane for complaining about this thank you and if you wanna know how I designed my Ninja OC I referenced earlier I might describe in comments, but you know I don't think it's important enough to elaborate on it in the post.