r/DeathBattleMatchups • u/MrRKeegan My matchup isn't popular enough for its own flair • 17d ago
Debate DEBATE CHART: Four vs Flumpty (Battle For Dream Island vs One Night At Flumpty’s)
3
u/MrRKeegan My matchup isn't popular enough for its own flair 17d ago
This debate chart was requested by u/SKR8_REAL
1
4
u/MrRKeegan My matchup isn't popular enough for its own flair 17d ago
Who takes Strength?
11
u/Freddy999M The second coming vs Henry stickmin fan 17d ago
Flumpty is complex multi vs Four's low multi. However, Flumpty would nerf himself so it's practically a tie
1
u/Adventurous_Tie_530 Kyle vs Simon Fan 17d ago
Flumpty isnt complex multi
Hes 5D at best as he doesnt get fnaf world scaling
2
5
u/MrRKeegan My matchup isn't popular enough for its own flair 17d ago
Who takes Intelligence?
8
5
1
u/ThatOneGamer_57 4️⃣Four vs Flumpty Fan🥚 16d ago
Tie, can't rlly decide who between the 2 would be smarter
1
4
u/MrRKeegan My matchup isn't popular enough for its own flair 17d ago
Who takes Hax?
6
3
4
u/Freddy999M The second coming vs Henry stickmin fan 17d ago
Four has more variety, but Flumpty overall has stronger haxes. Plot manip, law manip, etc
2
1
u/Adventurous_Tie_530 Kyle vs Simon Fan 17d ago
4 also has plot hax and law manipulation via upscaling from book
3
u/Freddy999M The second coming vs Henry stickmin fan 17d ago
Not really. Book has a specific ability that she only has because... she is a book. Four hasn't shown any proof of having any similar ability like Book's. Even if we say that Four has it, Flumpty resists plot and law manipulation either way
1
u/Adventurous_Tie_530 Kyle vs Simon Fan 17d ago
4 should scale to it via the host factor as it gives access to budget cuts that erase things from the plot and controls the entire show itself
3
u/Freddy999M The second coming vs Henry stickmin fan 17d ago
Four hasn't even shown to have that. By this argument, TV, because he was a host, should have plot manipulation. Four can control the show with his own powers, Announcer can control the show with his own tricks, there isn't really something that connects them nor an argument solid enough to give Four plot manipulation
and again, Flumpty resists it, so
(what might happend is Four stealing Flumpty's powers like how he did with Two, then he would have plot manip)
4
u/MrRKeegan My matchup isn't popular enough for its own flair 17d ago
Who takes Weapons?
4
4
u/ThatOneGamer_57 4️⃣Four vs Flumpty Fan🥚 16d ago
Definitely Four. Flumpty may have a few weapons but Four's weapons are far more powerful and impactful
3
1
3
3
u/MrRKeegan My matchup isn't popular enough for its own flair 17d ago
Who takes Durability?
8
5
2
u/Equivalent_Ant6794 The second coming vs Henry stickmin fan 17d ago
Four because Flumpty's physical durability is lil inconsistent
2
0
3
3
u/MrRKeegan My matchup isn't popular enough for its own flair 17d ago
Who takes Experience?
9
u/SympathyImaginary718 My matchup isn't popular enough for its own flair 17d ago
Flumpty, he has existed since The start of time
2
u/Adventurous_Tie_530 Kyle vs Simon Fan 17d ago
So has the contestants as bfdi has no concept of age
4
5
3
3
u/MrRKeegan My matchup isn't popular enough for its own flair 17d ago
Who takes Powers?
6
2
2
2
u/ThatOneGamer_57 4️⃣Four vs Flumpty Fan🥚 16d ago
TMK, Four has more versatile and number of powers than Flumpty overall.
2
3
3
u/MrRKeegan My matchup isn't popular enough for its own flair 17d ago
Who takes Combat?
5
u/Equivalent_Ant6794 The second coming vs Henry stickmin fan 17d ago edited 16d ago
Four has fought before
5
u/ThatOneGamer_57 4️⃣Four vs Flumpty Fan🥚 16d ago
Four probably since they've been shown to have experience in combat
1
3
u/MrRKeegan My matchup isn't popular enough for its own flair 17d ago
Who takes Range?
6
3
u/ThatOneGamer_57 4️⃣Four vs Flumpty Fan🥚 16d ago
Both, both have many ways of attacking or perceiving eachother from nearly limitless distances
0
3
u/MrRKeegan My matchup isn't popular enough for its own flair 17d ago
Who takes Stamina?
5
2
u/caliBOI78 My matchup isn't popular enough for its own flair 16d ago
I'd say tie as to my knowledge, neither side has shown many signs of being extremely exhausted, aside from Four trying to absorb Spongy
1
3
3
3
3
u/MrRKeegan My matchup isn't popular enough for its own flair 17d ago
Who's the Overall Winner and what Difficulty?
9
u/SympathyImaginary718 My matchup isn't popular enough for its own flair 17d ago
Flumpty High difficulty
3
6
2
2
u/MrRKeegan My matchup isn't popular enough for its own flair 17d ago
Who takes Unique Stat for this MU?
12
u/ThatOneGamer_57 4️⃣Four vs Flumpty Fan🥚 17d ago
Henchmen/Minions: Four
Four's contestants generally scale higher
1
-3
1
16d ago
[deleted]
1
u/Equivalent_Ant6794 The second coming vs Henry stickmin fan 16d ago
when the shitpost goes too far basically
-9
4
u/MrRKeegan My matchup isn't popular enough for its own flair 17d ago edited 17d ago
Rules:
How I decide the catagories: I will take all the upvotes from each comments in the catagory and which ever character has the most upvotes in total will take the catagory.
No Downvoting: It accomplishes nothing and only makes things worse for the rest who're expecting a fair debate. If I recieve upto date evidence of vote rigging, I will suspend the perpetrator(s) for 2-weeks.
Give an Explanation: When choosing who takes Strength, Speed, etc, please give a rough or thorough explanation for your choice. A link to a source to back up your reasoning would also help, if you're able to.
No Favouritism: We all don't like to see our favourite characters lose but in a debate we must put those feelings aside for a fair and equal fight.
Strength = Physical output (e.g. How strong are they, how much can they lift, etc).
Powers = more conventional advantages like flying, ice breath, super speed.
Hax = weirder abilities like Gojo’s infinite, temporal lock, death immunity.
Attack Potency = the amount of destructive capacity they can produce.
Combat = knowledgable with martial arts/H2H (e.g. Boxing, Judo, etc).
Abilities = non-superhuman things like aiming, jumping, etc.