r/Firefighting • u/JruePeakcock hose toucher • Feb 24 '25
Ask A Firefighter So I did a thing
Anyone ever seen this before?
124
u/Paramedickhead Feb 24 '25
Yes.
Guy got tired of drunks constantly crashing into his pipe fence.
So he rebuilt it out of thick wall drill pipe.
When we inevitably had to go for the next drunk, I broke two sets of blades before realizing what we were up against.
Also, the halo in an INDYCAR is so stout, the largest Holmatro cutter available will make two cuts, then the entire tool requires rebuild or replacement.
12
u/ip_addr Feb 24 '25
The halo is titanium, and I believe the cutters are also titanium, right? So its kind of an even match.
6
u/Paramedickhead Feb 24 '25
I can’t say for sure. I just know that the tracks where I work the touring safety team guys tell us that our cutters aren’t up to the job.
It isn’t so much an issue with the blades from what I understand, it’s more of an issue with the pressures inside the tool.
52
u/The_mans_a_champion Feb 24 '25
14
u/JruePeakcock hose toucher Feb 24 '25
how'd it happen to ya
57
1
49
42
u/ProfessorPatrick_ Feb 24 '25
I don’t mess with cutters on hinges now. Once they start giving me shit I’m on the spreaders just rip them out
18
u/Theantifire TYFYS Feb 24 '25 edited Feb 24 '25
Works 99% of the time 👌. Though remember that spreaders can cause unwanted movement at times that a cutter won't.
4
u/lostinthefog4now Feb 25 '25
Throughout my career , I was taught not to cut the hinge or the Nader bolt. Use the jaws to rip hinge out of the sheet metal was what we were taught. And this was before the E-tools came out.
3
u/Fuzztu_Boogerball Feb 25 '25
I have not used cutters on hinges unless it just can't be spread. For the past 10 years now at least. I thought I was crazy seeing this.
I'm more inclined to think they cut the seatbelt plate. I've never seen hinges that we're actually hard.
1
u/ProfessorPatrick_ Feb 25 '25
Where I’m from we have a lot of European cars which use a cast hinge. They are insanely strong. A lot of Japanese cars use a rolled hinge which just fall apart once some pressure is put on them. The way I was taught was to carefully shatter the glass then use the spreaders to crush the door exposing the lock then push the spreaders into that gap and spread it open till the lock catch pops. Alternately crush the panel in front of the A pillar to expose the hinges and essentially do the same thing to rip the hinges out of the steel. Which good cribbage the vehicle should be firmly supported to limit movement and eliminate risk of further injuring the entrapped persons
49
u/chuckqc Feb 24 '25
Let me guest... c-Shift
38
u/Level9TraumaCenter Feb 24 '25
It was like that when I found it.
37
u/chuckqc Feb 24 '25
Remind me of this old joke. You leave 3 bowling balls in a station, you come back later, one missing, one broken and the last one is pregnant
13
u/GweepLathandas Feb 24 '25
I think you meant that C-Shift did a thing and you just found it that way.
12
17
u/SkibDen Euro trash LT Feb 24 '25
Guess there is a reason they kept saying "don't cut the hinges, they are the strongest part of a car" at the academy..
We did too not to long ago, because someone wanted to test out why you don't cut hinges....
24
4
u/Sad-Pay5915 Feb 24 '25
Not sure how you guys go about cutting the bottom hinge but usually we will drop the top hinge with spreaders then attack the bottom hinge from the top straight down with the cutters. That way you’re attacking the thinnest part of the hinge
4
u/beachmedic23 Paramedic/FF Feb 24 '25
Cutters are overrated. Put them away. you can accomplish 98% of extrication with the spreaders. the other 2% with a high lift jack and a chain
3
3
u/Teejay91b Feb 24 '25
I’ve talked to Hurst. They advised us not to try to cut the hinges. They recommended using the spreaders to tear the hinges off the body. This was after we’d snapped the blades on our cutters.
2
u/rawkguitar Feb 24 '25
We have TNT. We cut hinges all the time. Never broke blades.
1
u/Teejay91b Feb 25 '25
I can only speak for the Hurst brand. Our Hurst cutter had the exact same failure as the one pictured.
3
3
3
u/Fantastic_Ease_3261 Feb 27 '25
That’s becaue you were not wearing black socks in your station boots.
2
u/ZedZero12345 Feb 24 '25
Ok so totally off topic. Why does your stream light have a red collar? Btw, the Hurst had it coming.
1
u/JruePeakcock hose toucher Feb 24 '25
No idea tbh, probably broke the original and got replaced with the red collar
2
2
2
u/AtopMountEmotion Feb 24 '25
This is why we can’t have nice things. Go to the hose tower and think about what you’ve done.
2
u/TheCopenhagenCowboy Fire Medic Feb 24 '25
The cutters are fragile af if they start to twist or bind, gotta pay attention to your tool while you cut
2
2
2
2
2
u/Tylerdurdin174 Feb 25 '25
I’ve been there brother ….prepare to get chewed out short term and get ur balls broken long term
2
2
2
5
u/worst_episode__ever Feb 24 '25
The only thing you could have been cutting was the jaws of another Hurst.
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Klb818 NY VFF Feb 24 '25
Yeh I’ve seen that happen. A guy was cutting a hinge in the seat and snapped the blade right off
2
u/msova2 Feb 24 '25
I’ve done that with an Amkus. Seat hinges are tough.
1
u/Klb818 NY VFF Feb 25 '25
Yeh you’re really not suppose to cut them. If you have to to get the seat down, I try to cut low. Least amount of steel ti get through and you don’t risk hitting the patient
1
1
u/Highspeed_gardener Feb 24 '25
Never broke the cutters but I did break the ram once. $13k mistake 🤬
1
1
u/Resqu23 Edit to create your own flair Feb 24 '25
The main issue here is that the tool doesn’t say AMKUS 😂 In 37 years I have never broke an AMKUS.
1
1
u/ApexTheOrange Feb 24 '25
We’re going to see a lot more of these over the next few years. 7000 series aluminum was a bad choice. It gets brittle after 10 years because of the annealing process. Heat treated 6000 series aluminum doesn’t have this problem.
1
1
1
u/Sure_Replacement_931 Feb 24 '25
Lower B-Post, can’t remember the model, no hardened mental. The person was using the tool, seemed to be going fine, then pop. The tool broke just like you see in the photo. Could have had a hair line fracture or something beforehand.
1
u/hav1t Operational WM - Fire Safety Inspector Feb 24 '25
I'm guessing you didn't check for twist in the angle.
1
1
1
1
u/floofydoggoUwU GA FF/EMT Feb 24 '25
Pov, you're relieving B-shift after they said they had a "small" entrapment.
Seriously, how is that even possible 😭
1
u/Every_Iron_4494 Feb 24 '25
I did that exact thing with that same brand. I guess I was torquing the tool as I was cutting a door hinge.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Successful-Growth827 Feb 24 '25
Yup. My buddy and I did this in VMO class. We were cutting through the passenger seat of a Benz and just when we thought we got it, we pulled out the cutters and saw this exact same thing.
Pretty much if the cutters start twisting, stop, or you'll potentially snap it like this.
1
1
1
1
u/dangforgotmyaccount previous intern Feb 25 '25
“I” “broke” the brake handle off of a chainsaw once, but never anything like THIS, and I seemingly break something daily
1
1
1
1
u/Exact-Location-6270 Feb 25 '25
“That’s me. You’re probably wondering how I got here. Well, it all started……”
1
1
1
-1
0
316
u/Dweide_Schrude FFII/EMT-A Feb 24 '25
You hurt the Hurst!
What were you cutting??