School phone bans expand to 35 US states, sparking national debate | Teachers report fewer disruptions after states limit student phone use

[u/chrisdh79]

https://www.techspot.com/news/109168-school-phone-bans-expand-17-additional-states.html

[u/chrisdh79]

From the article: The big picture: Restricting cell phone use has become one of the most significant policy shifts in schools in recent years. In just two academic years, what started as an isolated measure in Florida has grown into a national debate involving nearly three dozen states, as well as educators, parents, and researchers. While it's still too early to determine its full impact, the restrictions have already reshaped the daily routines of millions of students.

Seventeen states and the District of Columbia began this academic year with new limits on student cellphone use, marking one of the fastest-moving trends in American education policy. With the latest additions, a total of 35 states now have laws or rules restricting phones and other electronic devices during the school day.

The rapid adoption of these policies follows Florida's 2023 law – the first statewide mandate of its kind – and represents a rare instance of bipartisan agreement. Lawmakers from both parties argue that phone use interferes with learning and student well-being. Supporters link phones to classroom disruptions and reduced focus, while critics contend that the evidence is not yet conclusive.

The scope of the bans varies by state. Several prohibit phones throughout the school day. Some, such as Georgia and Florida, enforce "bell-to-bell" restrictions only for kindergarten through eighth grade. Seven states limit prohibitions to class time, allowing students to use devices during lunch or passing periods. Other states leave it to districts to set their own policies, often with the implicit expectation that tighter controls will follow.

Classroom enforcement differs widely. Some students begin the day by placing phones in magnetic lockable pouches or retrieving loaner devices from dedicated storage lockers.

Early reports suggest students are adjusting to the new limits, though reactions remain mixed. At McNair High School near Atlanta, where restrictions began last year, junior Audreanna Johnson told the Associated Press that initial pushback is starting to ease. Many students initially resisted turning over their phones because they were used to texting classmates and socializing during lessons.

Still, some students note drawbacks. Johnson said she relies on music through headphones to concentrate on schoolwork and expressed frustration at losing that option.

At Kentucky's Doss High School, senior Jamel Bishop observed that the ban is reshaping classroom dynamics. With fewer interruptions, he said, teachers can provide "more one-on-one time for the students who actually need it."

Parents are equally conflicted. Researchers at Emory University, who surveyed 125 Georgia school districts, found that parental resistance is the single largest obstacle to regulating phone use in schools. Many parents want reassurance that they can contact their children immediately in case of emergencies.

Parent advocates such as Jason Allen of the National Parents Union argue that schools need to address both safety communication and social-emotional development when implementing restrictions. "We just changed the cellphone policy, but aren't meeting the parents' needs," Allen said.

Evidence on the impact of phone bans is still emerging. Teachers often welcome the policies, reporting calmer classrooms and easier instruction.

Julie Gazmararian, a public health professor at Emory studying a ban in Marietta middle schools, said educators observed fewer disruptions and more student interactions in hallways and cafeterias. Discipline referrals also declined, though she cautioned that her research is ongoing and cannot yet determine whether mental health outcomes or bullying rates are changing.

Other scholars urge caution. Munmun De Choudhury, a Georgia Tech professor, noted that while social media use strongly correlates with poor mental health, research has not proven causation. "We need to be able to quantify what types of social media use are causing harm, what types of social media use can be beneficial," she said.

Despite growing momentum, not all legislatures are on board. Earlier this year, Wyoming's Senate defeated a bill requiring districts to adopt cellphone policies, with opponents arguing that decision-making should remain with teachers and parents. In Michigan, a Republican proposal for a statewide ban in K-8 classrooms and high school instructional periods failed in the House after Democrats objected on grounds of local control.