Edit: I’ve since learned that my loans would count toward old-IBR (started taking them out pre-July 2014), so I would need to make 300 payments instead of 240 and it would be 15% of my income instead of 10%. With that in mind and my goal being forgiveness, it seems best to resume payments now to start moving toward forgiveness and switch to PAYE (10% of income payments) until it ends in 2028, and then in 2028, switch to old-IBR vs. RAP for my specific situation.
—————————
Hello,
I did my best to scan past posts but couldn’t find anything specific to my situation (correct me if I’m wrong). I appreciate any advice or information. My main goal is pay as little as possible over the lifetime of my loan (by means of forgiveness and tax bomb), while keeping my monthly payment as reasonable as possible (I have low expenses, single, no dependents).
I have $321k in mostly grad school loans (consolidated in 2018 w undergrad loans, $308k principle, $13k accrued interest, 6.0% interest rate) with MOHELA, currently on SAVE. Undergrad loans were 2009-2013, grad loans were 2013-2017. I am not doing PSLF (was initially, but life happened and no longer working for a PSLF qualifying job).
Context: I graduated from graduate school in 2017 and started making monthly payments on my loans in 12/2017 as a resident physician. The timing of all these changes with payment plans and forbearance made it so I had been locked into a payment of $295 based on my resident salary when SAVE forbearance began, even though I graduated in 2021 and have had an attending salary (~$220k) since 07/2021. Essentially, my higher salary had yet to affect my monthly payment amount.
I haven’t been making payments since the SAVE forbearance started. Ideally, I would have liked to continue making the $295 monthly qualifying payments toward eventual forgiveness since eventually my monthly payment will go up significantly, and I could get much cheaper qualifying payments. But it’s my understanding that even if I continued making these payments during forbearance, it wouldn’t count toward my qualifying payments toward IBR forgiveness.
My next IDR recertification date is 9/15/2026.
As I see it, my top options are:
1) sit in SAVE, do nothing for now: not make payments, not progress toward forgiveness, have interest accrue, try to set aside money in a HYSA or make payments on interest (which feels like throwing money into the ether). It says my estimated payoff date would be 9/15/2026?
2) switch to IBR sooner rather than later: resume making payments, my monthly payment would increase ($1653), but I would start making progress toward forgiveness
Are there other options or something else I haven’t considered? Perhaps I don’t understand options 1 and 2 properly? It seems like I want to avoid getting into RAP and that IBR would be better for me. Are there any kind of non-PSLF “buyback” options that would allow me to retroactively pay forbearance payments at my $295 rate to count toward my overall qualifying payments? (For instance, could I pay back 10 months’ worth of forbearance payments for $2950 and count that toward my IBR forgiveness date so I don’t have to make 10 payments adjusted for my now higher salary?)
I’m getting closer to resigning myself that I will never pay these off, or that maybe I’ll have them forgiven and be hit with a nasty tax bomb. But I want to make sure I can do what I can now to avoid worsening my situation. I already regret taking out these loans in the first place and would hate to regret a decision made during this tumultuous and uncertain time.
Thank you,