Husband and I are high school sweethearts. We are in our late 20s. He has a friend ‘Kelly’ who has also known him since high school, they worked together for a bit in HS as well and they’re part of a larger friend group. I’m happy he has friends who he can spend time with and can do things Im not always interested in, particularly partying into the late hours of the night.
The problem for me started when after a night out with his friends, my husband shared with me that Kelly tried to drunkenly kiss him, and he rejected her. He shared that with me as soon as he got home and he seemed very upset about her trying to do that. We talked about it and he said he would have a conversation with her the next time they saw each other, to which she said that she had no memory of the event but she felt bad about it happening. Apparently she had also tried to do that with another friend in the group and was also going through a rough breakup at the time.
After that, my husband saw her less and made a point to not be alone with her. After everything cooled off he suggested that maybe it would be a good idea for me to get to know her and set up a hangout at a bar with us, Kelly and her sibling. She was nice/cordial but it was a little awkward because she kept trying to figure out a meeting with a drug dealer and kept wandering away from the group. All of the pictures she posted about the night left me out, but included my husband and her sibling. There have been a handful of times I joined the group hangouts, and they’ve gone well, but i still feel uncomfortable when people make jokes and references about things I don’t understand because they have a long history of friendship. Which is fine, I keep it to myself and try to enjoy myself, but still stings a little. Whenever I bring it up to my husband he reassures my feelings and he always makes a point to include me.
A few months ago they all went on a trip out of state and my husband was so excited, and I was excited for him. I was invited but I didn’t go because I didn’t really want to, thats HIS friend group and I had other things planned that weekend. Everything was fine until I saw Kelly posts a series of pictures from the trip, the cover photo being her and my husband. To ME, and this is definitely based on heteronormative bias, they look like a couple at first glance. Theres no physical contact but she’s in a bikini and heavily leaning towards him and is arching her back a lot. (Husband is wearing flannel and shorts—which is part of why I feel irrational, because of course she’s wearing a swimsuit if they’re swimming in a creek. She’s just very cute in the photo and she’s standing next to my man so it made me feel this weird jealousy when it popped up on my feed.)
I also brought up my feelings about this post and told my husband I can’t help but feel a little disrespected by her. She has other posts where it’s just the two of them, my husband is neutrally facing the camera and she’s leaning into him like that or theyre sitting very close. Those photos are always the first cover photo of the posts with other friends. My husband said he never thought of it like that but can understand why that bothers me. I asked him not to bring it up with her because I feel stupid for even feeling this way.
Part of me knows I’m angry because she’s just very beautiful and it makes me feel a pit in my stomach knowing my husband has such an attractive friend. He says he has no attraction to her and I believe him, he’s always been honest with me and we have always had great communication.
To be clear, I don’t feel like my relationship is being threatened. I just feel possessive. I have OCD and have been silently obsessing over this whole thing for weeks now. It’s so frustrating because I think it would be best to just let it go. But on the other hand I’m upset at my husband for still hanging out with her even if it’s with a larger group. And i’m upset at her because I feel jealous.
Am I being irrational here? Has anyone else gone through something similar? Am I being controlling? Please help. I’m trying to be mature about this and not let my emotions cause a rift in my husband’s friend group.