r/Wellthatsucks Jul 10 '24

[deleted by user]

[removed]

16.4k Upvotes

6.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

5

u/rbartlejr Jul 10 '24

Have you ever seen a 3" hose under pressure? They don't bend, it has to be a gentle curve. Think very oversized garden hose made of layers ending with sandpaper (rough canvas) on the outer layer. If you kink the hose, no water. If you kink the hose and then release it rapidly you get a water hammer. You have then, most likely, damaged the hydrant.

10

u/h4ppidais Jul 10 '24

More kinks by breaking the window 🤷‍♂️

2

u/Opposite-Store-593 Jul 10 '24

You can't say "more" when you don't have a comparison of what it would look like without going through the windows here.

For all we know, that's fewer kinks than would have been present by bending the hose around or over the car. I kinda doubt it, but we don't know because there isn't a video of them doing that to this vehicle.

2

u/aircooledJenkins Jul 10 '24

There is zero scenario where draping the hose on top of this car and allowing it to find its own path between the hydrant and the engine results in more kinks than forcing it through the small rigid openings of two car windows.

0

u/Opposite-Store-593 Jul 10 '24

Zero seems pretty extreme. Source?

More speculation?

1

u/aircooledJenkins Jul 10 '24

Source: I have eyes and a solid understanding of geometry and pathfinding.

1

u/Opposite-Store-593 Jul 10 '24 edited Jul 11 '24

Do you have a solid understanding of the mechanics behind a fire hose, both under pressure and not?

How about the material?

The length of this specific hose?

The pressure of this hydrant, and therefore the water pressure through the hose?

Nah, you just know it. /s🙄

1

u/aircooledJenkins Jul 10 '24

I'm glad we agree.

1

u/Opposite-Store-593 Jul 10 '24

That's what I thought. 🙄