r/amandaknox • u/SeaCardiologist6207 • 10d ago

Beyond Motive - How would Knox and Sollecito conspire with Guede to do this?

One thing I have never understood in reading this sub is beyond the motive explanation - what makes you so sure that Knox and Sollecito are guilty when they would 100% have to have done this with Rudy Guede. It's a mathematical impossibility that Rudy wasn't there, so your basic claim is then that they both conspired with some random person they served a drink once in a bar, and possibly met at a party, to murder and torture someone? Do you actually listen to what you are proposing logically? That a white American, Italian, and African would somehow become a criminal gang and plan out a crime?

Not only that, but you would assume that 3 people would be able to commit such a crime in a way that they could both cover all of each other's tracks (not have 1 of the 3 have overwhelming evidence present at the crime)? And that Rudy would be the one to do all the killing and somehow have agreed to this? And taken a dump in the toilet and left it there? No one would have told him "hey dude, not a good idea"?

There is no reasonable path to finding them guilty unless you believe they conspired with Rudy and that evidence is so incredibly thin (unless you are that commenter that somehow believes Rudy is innocent, I can't tell if its wife or mom).

What exactly is the theory on how all 3 of them did it that doesn't sound completely ridiculous?

20 Upvotes

92% Upvoted

38 comments sorted by

View all comments

9

u/bensonr2 10d ago

Don't waste your breath. You will never get any answer other then mixed dna, she did cartwheels and every other bit of nonsense.

There is already a thread from the past couple days postulating this and non of the guilters for the most part will give a beginning to end crime theory.

6

u/SeaCardiologist6207 10d ago

And then the inevitable "you are blocked because you are challenging me". It just seems to be a pattern throughout the whole sub - i get that she did strange things and there is circumstantial evidence against her but some people can't get over the "weight of the evidence" factor. She lived in a house with this person - her DNA would be there. She met Guede and served him a drink - so?

2

u/Angry_Sparrow 10d ago

It isn’t strange to do the splits (which she did). As someone that does splits, you need to stretch at least every 2-3 days. It feels really bad to not stretch - you can feel your body tighten up. Stretching is also a very mindful way to destress. It brings you into your body and out of your mind.

To me saying it’s strange she was stretching in the police station is like saying she went for a walk to clear her head and it was strange that she did so.

6

u/SeaCardiologist6207 10d ago

Or Amanda going to buy underwear / lingerie - this is a sign of guilt ? Because it’s “sexy”?

3

u/Angry_Sparrow 10d ago

Exactly. Trying to maintain a normal routine and a normal life is what anyone would do in the same situation.

She was alone in a foreign country with only her Italian lover to help her process the situation and to keep her from fully dissociating. I think without Raffaelle there she might have completely cracked.

0

u/jasutherland innocent 9d ago

Never mind that Sollecito was obviously joking about the rather child-like red underwear with a cow on being "sexy" - something the cashier probably misunderstood since it was noted they spoke very little English.