r/amandaknox • u/SeaCardiologist6207 • 10d ago

Beyond Motive - How would Knox and Sollecito conspire with Guede to do this?

One thing I have never understood in reading this sub is beyond the motive explanation - what makes you so sure that Knox and Sollecito are guilty when they would 100% have to have done this with Rudy Guede. It's a mathematical impossibility that Rudy wasn't there, so your basic claim is then that they both conspired with some random person they served a drink once in a bar, and possibly met at a party, to murder and torture someone? Do you actually listen to what you are proposing logically? That a white American, Italian, and African would somehow become a criminal gang and plan out a crime?

Not only that, but you would assume that 3 people would be able to commit such a crime in a way that they could both cover all of each other's tracks (not have 1 of the 3 have overwhelming evidence present at the crime)? And that Rudy would be the one to do all the killing and somehow have agreed to this? And taken a dump in the toilet and left it there? No one would have told him "hey dude, not a good idea"?

There is no reasonable path to finding them guilty unless you believe they conspired with Rudy and that evidence is so incredibly thin (unless you are that commenter that somehow believes Rudy is innocent, I can't tell if its wife or mom).

What exactly is the theory on how all 3 of them did it that doesn't sound completely ridiculous?

20 Upvotes

92% Upvoted

38 comments sorted by

View all comments

4

u/[deleted] 10d ago

Generally I agree, however there is at least one person who was active on this sub in the past who believed Guede’s account of being an innocent bystander (another option). Also one could argue that Knox and Sollecito stabbed Kercher and then left and Guede sexually assaulted her dying body. Also there is the possibility they were merely present at the time of the murder or even soon after, when she was dead or appeared dead, and covered this up for whatever reason all this time. But I think Occam’s Razor falls on Knox and Sollecito being uninvolved entirely and victims of bad police practice.

1

u/tkondaks 9d ago

"...and Guede sexually assaulted her dying body..."

Or Guede is innocent and the two ghouls staged a sexual assault on her body after returning to the house to conduct their clean-up. After all, they staged a break-in in Filomena's room, so I wouldn't put it past them to do some untoward things to the victim's body to stage a sexual assault.

3

u/jasutherland innocent 9d ago

You think they assaulted him using some part of Guede's body while leaving no trace of their own presence and Guede neither resisting at the time nor ever mentioning it to anyone later...? Is he your dealer and that's why you defend him so vehemently?