On July 18, I bought a Xiaomi 15 phone from Amazon Italy for €800, paid in installments,first payment was €160. On July 23, I returned the phone using the only method they offered: pickup by SDA Carrier.
The courier came to my house, I handed him the phone, asked to see the return label, and took a photo of it. But he didn't attach the return label to the package in front of me , he was setting in the car opened his window I gave him the phone he took the return label in his hand and ask me to take the photo so I took the photo and he left as showing in the photo ,Five days later, I checked the return status and saw this message:
"Your package was lost during transit. We lost your package."
I contacted Amazon support. They said they'd investigate. The next day, they replied:
"Your package was not lost. We received your package, but it was empty. Please return the correct item so we can issue the refund."
Excuse me? Empty?
I went straight to the SDA Carrier office to investigate. They confirmed the package was sent to Amazon with a recorded weight of 700 grams. So it wasn’t empty. Now I had three conflicting stories:
- Amazon app says lost in transit
- Amazon support says empty package
- SDA Carrier says package was 700g and sent properly
I was furious. I made two videos:
1. At the SDA office confirming the package wasn’t empty.
2. With the same courier who picked up the phone from my house (I saw him again when returning another item).
And I send both of the videos to Amazon , in the meantime,I blocked any future payments to Amazon. I paid using Revolut, so I’m filing a dispute to recover the €160 I already paid.
Then today, I got another email from Amazon’s specialist team:
"We received an incorrect item. Once you return the correct item, we will issue the refund."
So now it’s not “empty” it’s “incorrect.”
This company is full of contradictions and lies. I don’t trust Amazon anymore, and I definitely don’t trust the carriers they send to my house. It’s too easy for someone to swap the item and claim it was empty or wrong.
I sent them a final email:
"I am leaving your platform. I will save all the evidence I have against you, and I will never buy from your platform again."
Tomorrow I’m filing my Revolut dispute for the €160. Amazon has lost my trust forever.
Advice to everyone in Italy or anywhere Amazon uses home pickup for returns:
1- Always record a full video of your return process.
2- Show yourself packing the item, sealing the box, and handing it to the courier.
3- Ask the courier to attach the return label in front of you.
Don’t ask me why. Just do it. You’ll thank yourself later.