deciding what stays in this sub

[u/Riobox]

[u/CR1MS4NE]

Scenario 1 is an antimeme

Scenario 2 is an antimeme

Scenario 3 is not an antimeme - antimemes require a joke setup without a punchline. This is neither

Scenario 4 is not an antimeme, it’s just a pun. Puns are almost never antimemes because the punchline is usually intrinsic to the pun

Scenario 5 can sometimes be an antimeme but the example given is more of a bonehurtingjuice (though there is some overlap)

Scenario 6 is an antimeme

Scenario 7 is usually an antimeme but may also be a BHJ

Scenario 8 is not an antimeme as there is no joke setup. See scenario 3

Scenario 9 is not an antimeme, see scenarios 3 and 8