r/baseball Major League Baseball • Mod Verified 16h ago

Players Only [Highlight] Cal Raleigh hits his 49th HR of the season, setting a new single-season record for a primary catcher

6.2k Upvotes

346 comments sorted by

u/trendingtattler 15h ago

This post has reached r/all or r/popular, which means it’s now being seen by a much wider audience outside our usual community. To help keep the discussion high-quality and protect the space from spam, trolling, and rule-breaking, we’ve turned on "Players Only" mode.

What that means:

  • Regular contributors (based on subreddit karma) can comment freely on the post while this mode is active.
  • Comments from users below that threshold will be held for review and approved if they are not rule-breaking.

Thanks for your understanding and for helping keep the conversation thoughtful and on-topic.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

812

u/HartfordWhaler Cleveland Guardians 16h ago

He is so fun to watch. Absolutely demolished that ball

218

u/NWbySW Seattle Mariners 15h ago

And the HR he hit before this was a 450ft NUKE.

28

u/SharksFanAbroad Oakland Athletics 15h ago

259mo tbf

→ More replies (1)

638

u/Pick6XPA San Diego Padres 16h ago

First catcher 50HR season incoming and we were all there to see it live.

430

u/Soft_Entry_4440 Toronto Blue Jays 16h ago

Not only that - doing it in the anti-Coors park.

195

u/seductivestain 15h ago

Cal Raleigh is Maritime Layer father

61

u/micleosea Seattle Mariners 14h ago

The Sogfather

→ More replies (1)

71

u/jaron_b Seattle Mariners 15h ago

Almost equal splits with 24 out of his 49 HRs hit at home.

52

u/NWbySW Seattle Mariners 15h ago

The marine layer checks under its bed for Big Dumper.

30

u/ChrisBenoitDaycare69 Seattle Mariners 15h ago

He reminds of Nelson Cruz where he just demolishes the ball so hard it goes out in any ballpark.

8

u/Mr_Beats_73 Miami Marlins 14h ago

I wonder how many he’d have in Yankee. The numbers would be ridiculous

13

u/lutefiskeater Seattle Mariners • Arizona Diamondbacks 14h ago

Somebody ran the numbers on that back when cal had just over 30 & it was less than one may think. He only netted like 2 or 3 more

16

u/tlsrandy Seattle Mariners 13h ago

He’s getting to the point where 4-6 extras home runs could be the difference between breaking meaningful records though

I think it’s still an interesting thought experiment. Just within reasonable bounds.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/kotalov16 Seattle Mariners • Arizona Diamondbacks 11h ago

The thing with Cal is that he has very few wallscraper homers, so putting him in a better homer park is just inherently only going to give him a few more. But I am very much getting my hopes up that he can manage to get to 63, so the more the merrier

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/smoresporn0 Kansas City Royals 12h ago

He passed Sal Perez. The K isn't exactly a launching pad, despite how visiting teams made it seem for a vast majority of its existence lol

→ More replies (1)

89

u/Esuu Seattle Mariners 15h ago

Also very possibly the first to ever hit 20 HR from each side in a season if he can get 1 more from the right.

42

u/IAmBecomeTeemo New York Yankees 14h ago

If he hits 55, that's more than Mantle's 1961 season, which I believe is the most for a switch hitter.

16

u/dizzyfingerz3525 Seattle Mariners 10h ago

Thiccy Mantle > Mickey Mantle

9

u/Scumwaffle 12h ago

Against modern pitching too.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/elgenie Chicago Cubs 14h ago

There are five weeks left in the season, so that seems rather likely.

18

u/GoBirds_WeAre Phanatic 14h ago

gonna laugh my dick off when he breaks Judge's "record"

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

586

u/_Elrond_Hubbard_ Seattle Mariners 16h ago

Cal Raleigh is the main character

342

u/nncyw Seattle Mariners 16h ago edited 15h ago

The Mariners are not competitors, they are protagonists

124

u/ROTCHunter Seattle Mariners 15h ago

Will always upvote Jon Bois

69

u/nncyw Seattle Mariners 15h ago

Part 7 coming soon…

31

u/vylain_antagonist Seattle Mariners 11h ago

Its 2018. And On a mild Sinaloa november evening in mexico, theres a springy, muscle bound white kid lining up on the infield for the Tomateros de Culiacan. No ones quite sure what hes doing; the coaching staff didnt have many details on a surfer kid from Placienta California. and he didnt offer up many either because, despite speaking excellent spanish, it was easier for him to pretend not to understand so he could avoid questions about the latina baddie in the stands who watched his every move.

All they knew was that he had been flirting with some teams in the majors up in the US, and that he hit pull side bombs for fun.

His name, is Dylan Moore. And with him, these Mariners, are about to sail, finally, into the 21st Century.

cue the elevator music

9

u/nncyw Seattle Mariners 10h ago

Absolute cinema

4

u/Jed1M1ndTr1ck Seattle Mariners 7h ago

I'm still grieving the end of Dylan Moore's Mariners tenure, and you spring this poetry on me out of the blue? Cruel

4

u/darwinpolice Seattle Mariners 11h ago

The Era of Dumping

36

u/hickopotamus Seattle Mariners 14h ago

If the Mariners are protagonists, then I think we're living in a horror movie 😂

→ More replies (2)

12

u/Champion-raven Milwaukee Brewers 14h ago

The stars are all aligning?

47

u/HerkulezRokkafeller Seattle Mariners 15h ago

6 years/$105 million is insane

3

u/clangan524 Chicago Cubs 9h ago

Main Catcher syndrome

225

u/simply_mea Seattle Mariners 16h ago

Love to SEA it

27

u/mysterysackerfice Los Angeles Angels • Dumpster Fire 16h ago

SEA man providing some pop

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Muthafuckaaaaa Toronto Blue Jays 16h ago

I sea what you did there

221

u/Emyrssentry Kansas City Royals 16h ago

70

u/OkInitiative4032 More flair options at /r/baseball/w/flair! 16h ago

This is art

53

u/vanillabear26 Seattle Mariners 15h ago

“He ties Salvador Perez, bless his heart” Rick said on the radio after the first one.

3

u/darwinpolice Seattle Mariners 11h ago

Salvy is so cool.

→ More replies (1)

793

u/TechnicalDecision160 Houston Astros 16h ago

Dude is INSANE!

219

u/mnsportsfan Minnesota Twins 16h ago

Double dump day !!

92

u/moshjeier Seattle Mariners • Oakland Athletics 16h ago

And it’s only the second inning!

102

u/Duckrauhl Seattle Mariners 16h ago

He's on pace for 9 home runs this game!

32

u/SeattleMana Seattle Mariners 15h ago

on pace for 9 Home runs this game so far

22

u/Duckrauhl Seattle Mariners 15h ago

Only the Mariners would hit 9 home runs in a game, but still allow the game to go into extra innings...

7

u/short_bus2009 14h ago

The game will either be 1-0, or 12-10. I don't make the rules

5

u/darwinpolice Seattle Mariners 11h ago

Or just flat out lose in the 9th, if we're playing KC.

36

u/NevermoreSEA Seattle Mariners 16h ago

He is INSANE! He is DANGEROUS! He needs to be INVOLUNTARILY COMMITTED TO A MENTAL HEALTH FACILITY AS SOON AS POSSIBLE!

5

u/ThePrussianGrippe Chicago Cubs 14h ago

He’s been incredible to watch this year, and I hope he keeps it going.

290

u/NotACuck420 Seattle Mariners 16h ago

102

u/_Elrond_Hubbard_ Seattle Mariners 15h ago

Her spirit was reborn today in popcorn boy

30

u/dataminimizer Seattle Mariners 15h ago

I need a gif of popcorn boy sharpish

69

u/Jay_Dubbbs Cleveland Guardians 15h ago

Are you guys accepting early applications for bandwagon fans? I’m okay devoting my life to ensuring cal Raleigh is MVP

44

u/TheRealCRex Seattle Mariners 15h ago

Welcome aboard. Prepare yourself for the highest of highs and the soul-crushingest lows of lows.

And yes I know you're a Cleveland fan.

→ More replies (4)

21

u/ChrisBenoitDaycare69 Seattle Mariners 15h ago

You dont want no part of this shit Dewey. It'll ruin your life.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/PM_ME_LASAGNA_ Seattle Mariners • Philadelphia Phillies 13h ago

Yes, and if your application is accepted, you’ll be sent a welcome gift of a Josh Naylor jersey

132

u/CaptainShinySnap Seattle Mariners 16h ago

"What is next? Well I suppose it's a matter of whether or not the last 43 years were an accident. Did the Seattle Mariners stumble blinding into the most bizarre stories and fascinating people, generation after generation, purely by chance? Or are there reasons? Are they eccentric because their lack of conquest allows them to be? Are they so geographically remote that the ceaseless march of normal can't reach them? Do their fans love them so unconditionally that they are allow to ferment into something so captivating? Are they touched by God? Will they always be like this?" Jon Bois "The History of the Seattle Mariners

30

u/YeOldeManDan Houston Astros 14h ago

A fellow Jon Bois enjoyer. If only his name was Bob Raleigh.

7

u/Few-Race-8527 Minnesota Twins 10h ago

That would be a Jon Bois field day. Speaking of which, first Bob HR in a long time was the other day.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Sea-Us-RTO 14h ago

Are they touched by God?

well theyre certainly touched, wouldnt necessarily say its by god.

→ More replies (1)

80

u/AverageFoxNewsViewer Seattle Mariners 15h ago

Jarred Kelenic died to give him that nickname.

20

u/The_Throwback_King Seattle Mariners 11h ago

If the largest legacy of Kelenic's time in Seattle is as the herald to The Big Dumper, I am okay with that.

3

u/TheRealSlimN8y Seattle Mariners 8h ago

“I herald his beginning. I herald your end. I herald…Big Dumper” -Jarred Kelenic, probably

→ More replies (1)

9

u/darwinpolice Seattle Mariners 11h ago

If WAR properly rated nickname creation, Kelenic would've been an MVP in 2021.

158

u/heyim_william Toronto Blue Jays 16h ago

HE CATCHES BALLS

HE SMASHES DONGS

HE HAS A FAT ASS

IT’S CAL FUCKIN’ RALEIGH

→ More replies (1)

71

u/kwcc24 Seattle Mariners 16h ago

Idk about you guys but it seems like to me out of all of the players, he may be the most valuable

320

u/aquaseafoamshame666 Los Angeles Dodgers 16h ago

this guy fucks.

49

u/ajteitel Arizona Diamondbacks 16h ago

This guy dumpa

→ More replies (2)

170

u/disapparate276 Seattle Mariners 16h ago

That man trots around the bases like an MVP

347

u/disapparate276 Seattle Mariners 16h ago

THATS MY MVP

164

u/NevermoreSEA Seattle Mariners 16h ago

Praying for voter fatigue.

130

u/horizonwisps World Baseball Classic 16h ago edited 15h ago

WAR definitely isn't everything, but he's within a .1 WAR difference to Judge who now has the DH penalty tanking his defensive value. He might not need any pity due to voter fatigue.

19

u/Reasonable_Skill_129 New York Yankees 16h ago

am i looking at a different fangraphs than yall cuz i am not seeing .1 WAR difference

71

u/horizonwisps World Baseball Classic 16h ago edited 13h ago

you have to change the split to "Live Stats - Full Season" to see changes as the games are happening

edit: just realized you can't see splits on the fwar leader board fresh off google. If you're on that page just click on "Major League Leaders", and then you can filter a bunch of stuff including splits

10

u/Bayou-Maharaja Seattle Mariners 15h ago

fWAR

→ More replies (6)

77

u/mansontaco Detroit Tigers 16h ago

Yankees might play judge out of the mvp at this rate

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (3)

28

u/sirernestshackleton Seattle Mariners 16h ago

MVP chants were strong after this homer in the stadium

→ More replies (1)

22

u/scrambles57 Los Angeles Dodgers 14h ago

Definitely my AL MVP. Catcher is just so much harder than anything else and it's an all-time catcher season.

86

u/ADirtyHookahHose Seattle Mariners 16h ago

I love Cal Raleigh. I love his name, I love the shape of his body, I love the way he plays. I eat a lot of boiled eggs and lift weights to try and be like this guy but I can't. There are 6 grams of protein in an egg but I can't eat enough to get big like him. Nice round muscles. They're smooth too, like the waves of the Strait of Juan de Fuca on a calm day. When I was a kid I ate big eggs to be hot like Junior, and I got some great results, some of the roundest muscles in my class, but these days I'm looking at 6 eggs a day and it's not good enough to pop Dumper style muscles out my scrawny arms ever since dad left.

4

u/hickopotamus Seattle Mariners 14h ago

Same

40

u/OriolesMets Baltimore Orioles • New York Mets 16h ago

6

u/kotalov16 Seattle Mariners • Arizona Diamondbacks 11h ago

And boy is my head is all the way up it

→ More replies (1)

105

u/Rojotrece Seattle Mariners 16h ago

That's my Dumper!

10

u/APM208 15h ago

Big Dumpus

31

u/HendriksAppreciator Chicago White Sox 16h ago

Guy might hit 50 before the end of the day. What a year.

5

u/JMFR95 Tampa Bay Rays 14h ago

60 even, so many games left

13

u/ilakausername Seattle Mariners 14h ago

The white sox fan literally meant by the end of today, not the end of the Season. This was his second homer of the day, and it was in the second inning.

Unfortunately, he did not hit 50 by the end of the day.

3

u/JMFR95 Tampa Bay Rays 12h ago

I'm fucking blind and missed the day part 😭

→ More replies (1)

99

u/burglin Washington Nationals 16h ago

A second Dumper Dong has hit the second deck

11

u/APM208 15h ago

DOUBLE DUMP DAY

24

u/pinetar321 Seattle Mariners 16h ago

That booty is majestic and I'm here for it

107

u/Wait_im_about_to Seattle Mariners 16h ago

We shall Dump on to the end! We shall Dump in France. We shall Dump on the seas and the oceans. We shall Dump with growing confidence and growing strength in the air. We shall defend our Dump whatever the cost may be! We shall Dump on the beaches. We shall Dump on the landing grounds. We shall Dump in the fields and in the streets. We shall Dump in the hills. Big Dumper shall never surrender!

→ More replies (1)

22

u/NatetheGration Seattle Mariners 16h ago

THAT'S MY FUCKING CATCHER RIGHT THERE

21

u/BigDumper_Is_My_Dad 16h ago

Thats my dad!! Dump on em!

21

u/Griffdogg92 Seattle Mariners 16h ago

He is averaging one home run per inning today

23

u/dmlfan928 Baltimore Orioles • Frederick Keys 16h ago

And there is still a month left. Insane season.

20

u/CalebosO4 Toronto Blue Jays 16h ago

What a guy, bro saw the donation sign and the Big Dumper put matters into his own hands.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/david-crz San Diego Padres 16h ago

12

u/gartho009 Seattle Mariners 13h ago

God I hope so

22

u/mo4r-pow4 Seattle Mariners 16h ago

AL MVP (unbiased opinion)

16

u/PugetSoundRecords 16h ago

LETS GOOOOO

16

u/evancomposer Milwaukee Brewers 16h ago

This man just absolutely wrecks

15

u/zvexler Atlanta Braves 16h ago

Nuking both of them this game is awesome

15

u/Turb0___ Texas Rangers 16h ago

I fear no man but that dumper scares me

14

u/beefytrout Texas Rangers 16h ago

doing it at home was awesome

15

u/Invisiblechimp Seattle Mariners 15h ago

Most HR ever by a catcher in a season. Done.

Most HR ever by a switch hitter in a season. Next.

Most HR ever by a Mariner in a season. Soon.

7

u/darwinpolice Seattle Mariners 11h ago

I genuinely never thought we'd see a Mariner pass Griffey in single-season homers, but he needs what, eight more to get there? With 31 games left, it's doable.

15

u/vylain_antagonist Seattle Mariners 16h ago

Who has seen the like of Cal Raleigh? Or seen the living semblance of him standing in the world? Caleb, that could best God at ball-throw or wrestling or pig-trailing or at the honeyed discourse of sweet Carolinan with jewels and gold for bards, or at the listening of distant harpers in a black hole at evening.

Oh where is the living human man who could beat Cal at the making of generous cheese? At the spearing of ganders? At the magic of thumb-suck? At the shaving of hog-hair? Or at the unleashing of long hounds from a golden thong in the full chase, sweet-fingered corn-yellow Cal, Cal that could carry an armed host from Almha to Slieve Luachra in the craw of his gut-hung knickers.

28

u/WabbitCZEN New York Yankees 16h ago

ALL HAIL THE MIGHTY DUMPER

29

u/Lstark5642 Baltimore Orioles 16h ago

It’s gonna be so stupid if he doesn’t win MVP.

14

u/SlatsAttack Seattle Mariners 16h ago

MVP, MVP, MVP!

13

u/NWbySW Seattle Mariners 15h ago

Call the doctor. It's lasting more than 4 hours.

13

u/the_gaymer_girl Toronto Blue Jays 14h ago

It’s wild that “greatest batting season by a catcher in the history of baseball” somehow isn’t runaway MVP.

→ More replies (4)

11

u/soda_cookie New York Yankees • San Francisco Giants 15h ago

Probably your AL MVP right there

11

u/IAmBecomeTeemo New York Yankees 13h ago

This shouldn't be possible. Catcher is a position that is notoriously hard on the body. He struggled a bit over the last few weeks, but he's still crushing homers in a ballpark that significantly suppresses offense. I think at this point he's passed Judge in the MVP race, and Judge is only barely worse than his last two MVP seasons.

32

u/ty_for_the_norseman Seattle Mariners 16h ago
Cal Raleigh Aaron Judge
Leads in HR, RBI Leads in AVG, OPS
Team is 69-60 Team is 69-60
Total WAR 7.3 (est after today) Total WAR 7.4

Tie goes to better nickname?

8

u/Budget-Ocelots Major League Baseball 16h ago

What is his pace? Is he still in the 60+ HR range?

23

u/ty_for_the_norseman Seattle Mariners 15h ago

Mariners have played 131/162 games (0.801). (1/0.801)=1.248. 1.248*49 = 61.2

He's on pace for 61 Homers after today!

→ More replies (1)

10

u/AdministrativeEase71 Seattle Mariners 15h ago

Back in the 60s after this homer I think.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

10

u/timberwolvesguy Minnesota Twins 16h ago

This dude is gonna get 60, isn’t he?

7

u/Gbrusse Seattle Mariners 16h ago

He had a pretty big slump not that long ago. Without it, 65 would be on the table.

5

u/AKAD11 Seattle Mariners 13h ago

He was still hitting homers during the slump. The issue was that was all he was doing.

9

u/CenturyLinkIsCheeks Chicago White Sox 16h ago

monster dongs

9

u/DaRealJZ Seattle Mariners 16h ago

Long may he reign!

6

u/Maulbert Seattle Mariners 16h ago

Long may he DUMP!

58

u/JayBuhnersBarber Seattle Mariners 16h ago

Best moment of my 35 years as a M's fans!

Bless the cheeks. That one was a friggin NUKE!!

59

u/MichaelRM Chicago Cubs 16h ago

Better than Edgar’s team-saving walkoff? Better than Felix perfect game? Better than Ichiro’s 254th hit? Damn. I mean Cal’s awesome but that’s a choice

20

u/kamarian91 16h ago

I mean the closest thing out of those 3 is Ichiro's 254th hit, all time MLB records in primary categories is pretty special, and depending on how many Cal ends up with he could cement the record for a long long time

→ More replies (4)

24

u/OccasionalGoodTakes Seattle Mariners 16h ago edited 9h ago

Its worth noting a lot of those were a long time ago.

Cals walkoff to send us to the playoffs is my best moment in mariners history. The historical tension of following this team for the past decades just makes it stand out more than anything else. I don't fault anyone for choosing this now too, because we are seeing history made after so much misery.

as i wrote this comment i forgot how truly impactful the double was. Blame my age, i was a tad too young to get it in the moment back then.

17

u/OldDekeSport Seattle Mariners 15h ago

Ill always go with The Double, but this is my favorite individual player moments for a Mariner. Ichiro setting hits record and Cal getting catcher HR record are far and away the top 2. If Cal catches Griffey at 56 and wins MVP that would cement this.

Cal also gets a boost because of the walkoff to end the drought and calling out our FO to go all in. He signed an extension and THEN does this. Man loves Seattle and we love him!

6

u/OccasionalGoodTakes Seattle Mariners 15h ago

Man, that second part really gets to the heart of this season being special. Cal is just that guy.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/JayBuhnersBarber Seattle Mariners 15h ago

Yeah, its hard to not go with The Double as a canonical "best moment." I don't believe we would have a Mariners with a Big Dumper to admire without that moment.

You're on point with the individual player moment qualification.

3

u/clutchheimer Seattle Mariners 12h ago

I was at the game today and I will still go with the double. This was great. I love it. But the double was AWESOME. Against the Yankees, playoffs, Niehaus at the top of his game. The double had everything.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/JayBuhnersBarber Seattle Mariners 16h ago

Literally could not have written it better myself.

Also, CATCHERS DON'T DO THIS. They rarely stay healthy enough, play enough games, or innately have this level of power.

I think people are seriously downplaying how special this is.

9

u/OccasionalGoodTakes Seattle Mariners 16h ago

I think people are seriously downplaying how special this is.

by the end of the season they won't be able to, cal has a lot of records he is still within striking distance of. 2 HR game record is the one i'm really pulling for.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/darthstupidious Seattle Mariners 14h ago

Yeah and while his defensive stats are a bit down this year, this is still the same guy who won the Platinum Glove last year. Having a guy like that suddenly find the ability to hit 50+ bombs... holy shit.

13

u/JayBuhnersBarber Seattle Mariners 16h ago

Yep. I watched them all happen. They were all great.

What Cal is doing supersedes the physical ability and stamina of most players. You can tell by how often catchers don't do this.

Like what you want. Rank it how you want. Everyone is witnessing something very special this summer.

10

u/ExpirjTec Houston Astros • Houston Astros 16h ago

not even the best moment in Raleigh's career lmfao

not even his best moment against the a's

6

u/MysteriousEdge5643 Seattle Mariners • FanGraphs 15h ago

That was the greatest moment of my life, I managed to luck out and get tickets to the game that night

8

u/OccasionalGoodTakes Seattle Mariners 16h ago

you're talking like "best moments" are empirical

7

u/vanillabear26 Seattle Mariners 15h ago

Tbh in that case it kinda is

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

17

u/IamChicharon Seattle Mariners 16h ago
  1. Cal Raleigh walk-off home run to clinch playoffs for the first time in a generation

  2. Felix perfect game

  3. This.

  4. “The double”

  5. Ichiro breaks single season hit record.

  6. Mike Cameron 4hrs in a single game

5

u/JayBuhnersBarber Seattle Mariners 16h ago

Sweet man.

3

u/IamChicharon Seattle Mariners 16h ago

That’s just my personal list as a mariner fan for almost 40 years lol.

I totally get why you put this Cal season at #1 though

3

u/JayBuhnersBarber Seattle Mariners 15h ago edited 15h ago

Lol, sorry. I came in hot there. Your list is killer, honestly.

If I were to list it out for me it'd be something like:

• 1 a. This

• 1b. Felix perfect game

• 2. "The double" (we wouldn't have the team now without it)

• 3. Cal's walk-off

• 4. Ichiro single season

• 5. The Cammy 4-banger

So I agree with you mostly.

3

u/IamChicharon Seattle Mariners 15h ago

Yeah I mean honestly my 1-5 are really just 1a,b,c,d,e and Cameron’s game is 2 lol

→ More replies (1)

4

u/byPCP Seattle Mariners 16h ago

it has been a hard life as a seattle mariners fan, but god dammit this makes it all worth it

→ More replies (5)

8

u/shield_anvil_ Seattle Mariners 16h ago

The Dumping continues forever 

7

u/spacedude2000 Seattle Mariners 16h ago

My goat

6

u/narfidy Seattle Mariners 16h ago

The ONE game I cant watch live while I'm on vacation...

5

u/neronga Major League Baseball 16h ago

MVP

6

u/SlatsAttack Seattle Mariners 16h ago

The man cannot stop dumping.

6

u/DJ_Byun Seattle Mariners 16h ago

O DUMPER! MY DUMPER!

5

u/imnotapotato140 Toronto Blue Jays 15h ago

That’s my MVP

6

u/GameBroJeremy Detroit Tigers 15h ago

HISTORY

7

u/GrizzlyBares Seattle Mariners 15h ago

I love that he gets to have Goldy call these monster blasts, it really has elevated this historic season.

14

u/Fleachair7 Toronto Blue Jays • Ace 16h ago

That’s Seattles dumper!

5

u/lastminutealways Seattle Mariners 16h ago

Take your curtain call, Cal!

5

u/Potential_Reveal_948 16h ago

This guy DUMPS.

6

u/gvon89 New York Mets 16h ago

I haven't followed baseball in a while but I remember piazza challenging for the record at 40 back in the day. This guy has 49 with a whole MONTH left. He might reach 60 at this rate.

5

u/Caedus New York Mets 15h ago

I think he might get 60 home runs now.

5

u/ratcalzone New York Yankees 15h ago

god I love this dude

8

u/DaRealJZ Seattle Mariners 16h ago

MVD!

4

u/kirukiru San Francisco Giants 16h ago

Make him mvp

4

u/Grahamshabam Mariner Moose 16h ago

LEFT CHEEK

RIGHT CHEEK

LEFT CHEEK

RIGHT CHEEK

4

u/Robbuffet Atlanta Braves 15h ago

This is wild. What is happening? What changed?? Happy for dumps

4

u/GOATmar_infante Kansas City Royals 15h ago

Friggin Cal

6

u/Individual_Judgment3 Chicago White Sox 15h ago

Rooting for Mariners/Brewers World Series

3

u/mahrinazz Seattle Mariners 16h ago

mariner

3

u/Riff726 Los Angeles Dodgers 15h ago

Big Dumper sets the record in the AsS game

3

u/Nights_King New York Mets 14h ago

We played one series against this man and I never wanna see him again

3

u/InfectiousCosmology1 San Francisco Giants 10h ago

MVP

21

u/Ok_Imagination_4374 Baltimore Orioles 16h ago

I know Judge deserves it but I want Cal to win MVP so fucking badly

23

u/CharlemagneOfTheUSA Boston Red Sox 16h ago

Cal is only 0.4 fWAR Behind coming into today, it’s still anyone’s MVP to win

15

u/MysteriousEdge5643 Seattle Mariners • FanGraphs 15h ago

He's cut the gap to 0.1 today with live stats

6

u/CharlemagneOfTheUSA Boston Red Sox 15h ago

Judge still has to play today obviously, but he’s having easily his worst month of the season right now, so Cal definitely has the chance to pull ahead there soon

34

u/swampninja Boston Red Sox 16h ago

Does he though? I think Cal may be running away with it.

33

u/Ok_Imagination_4374 Baltimore Orioles 16h ago

Judge leads Raleigh in a lot more stats BUT Raleigh is a catcher so you could make a strong case that Raleigh deserves it just as much since catchers NEVER do this. Raleigh is playing great defense while simultaneously having one of the greatest seasons by a catcher ever. I REALLY hope Cal gets it but Judge will probably get it for his on the surface stats.

12

u/teckmonkey Seattle Mariners 16h ago

Cal is also doing this as a switch hitter, just saying.

6

u/darkravenn12 More flair options at /r/baseball/w/flair! 14h ago

idk why people bring this up. Who the hell cares if he's a switch hitter LOL You don't get extra points for being a switch hitter. It doesn't mean anything. The only viable argument should be about whether the defensive gap between Cal and Judge is enough to offset the offensive gap between them, which is a very real argument and is probably basically a tossup right now.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

8

u/tuckedfexas Seattle Mariners 15h ago

Cal is still just barely behind him, but if Judge is only DH-ing it could easily be a close race to the end

7

u/EarthWarping Major League Baseball 16h ago

Eh... I think its a coin flip with Judges post ASB stats (IL stint tbf)

5

u/OccasionalGoodTakes Seattle Mariners 16h ago

vibes based MVP

5

u/Draw42 14h ago

Cal is arguably having the greatest season by a catcher ever.  Judge is probably having the 3rd best season by judge...

6

u/TechnicalSkunk Los Angeles Angels 16h ago

Why are people still pitching to him lol

12

u/MaynardsUnit 15h ago

That's the power of having threats around you in the lineup, and guys on base. What else can they do?

9

u/hickopotamus Seattle Mariners 14h ago

Honestly he's not very tough to pitch to when you execute your pitches. He’s hitting .200. I know he’s done damage against teams and I think if you execute, he’s obviously got big damage potential and he’s got a lot of strikeout potential, too, and when you execute your pitches, you usually get the job done.

5

u/Howboutit85 Seattle Mariners 13h ago

.200 is very different than .240-.250… especially in today’s game. Hitting .300 is almost a novelty now, and really really good hitters are in the .260-.270 range. We may even finish the season with only 4-5 guys hitting over 300. That’s how dominant pitching is now, and how little batters hit for contact vs hit for dingers. It’s just the way things are currently.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Thomasfire010 16h ago edited 16h ago

The actual Mvp

6

u/ALaccountant Atlanta Braves 15h ago

Surely the MVP, and not even close at this point, right? How much consideration does Judge get considering he's living off his performance from the first 2 months of the season?

2

u/xVIRIDISx Cleveland Guardians 15h ago

what a beautiful swing on that one

2

u/BoscoHype Seattle Mariners • Bellingham Bells 15h ago

ITS MY BIRTHDAY TODAY THANK YOU DUMPY

2

u/gietz77 Seattle Mariners 15h ago

Goldie's calls get me fired up

2

u/shockedtoo Detroit Tigers 15h ago

Mickey Tettleton wants his fruitloops back

2

u/RandallOfLegend Seattle Mariners 15h ago

His ability to do this from both sides of the plate is even more impressive