I've worn drone comps for the last 5 years and love them. They fit well, break in quickly to become "no-edge" and glom onto anything I step on, making them super fun gym shoes. But as a result, they are not so great for edging or precision.
My favorite style of climbing is "board" style and I would like to switch over to a more precise shoe with a stiffer edge, for climbing the moonboard. So I've tried a few - solutions, instinct vsr, and instinct S.
But having climbed in the drone CS for so many years and being so used to them, I kind of hate how any other shoe feels. And I can't tell if it's because they don't fit, because they need to break in more, or if it's just a different toe box shape and so it feels unfamiliar? I have to drop 2-3 moonboard grades to climb in any other show and they all just feel awful and insecure.
So my questions are:
1) How long do you give a new shoe to grow on you before writing it off? Do you know right away if it's a good fit and if you'll like it, or does it take a few sessions over a few weeks?
2) How do you know if a shoe is a bad fit or if it just needs to be broken in? Certain shoes I think are notorious for difficult break in such as the VSR's due to the hard rubber above the toe knuckles. I couldn't deal with the pain (could barely walk), but I don't know if it would have gotten better over a few weeks.
3) How do you guys switch shoes after just wearing a single pair for years and being so familiar with it? Do you just commit to powering through and sacrificing a few weeks of climbing to give the new ones a chance?