r/dankmemes ☣️ Jun 15 '24

OC Maymay ♨ Whoever dumped Millions into this is the biggest clown in the world

Post image
12.5k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

31

u/--_-Deadpool-_-- Jun 15 '24

The Mandalorian, Rogue One and Andor are all fantastic IMO.

I have a soft spot for the Prequels, and I think Revenge of The Sith is a legitimately good Star Wars movie.

Solo was fun, and I enjoyed Ashoka.

Boba Fett had good parts but was overall pretty bad.

The Sequel Trilogy is a hot mess.

So I'd say that the majority of SW:EU content is actually pretty good. But they have definitely missed the mark on more than one occasion.

-5

u/UncontrolledLawfare Jun 15 '24

most

Dig through enough shit and you’ll find kernels of corn. I’ll never say everything related to the IP sucks.

I'd say that the majority of SW:EU content is actually pretty good.

You just listed most of the things that weren’t awful. A LOT more came out than just that.

6

u/--_-Deadpool-_-- Jun 15 '24

I literally listed all the live action content other than The Acolyte, which I haven't seen yet.

1

u/UncontrolledLawfare Jun 15 '24

Obi Wan show? Did we really need to know the story of Han’s dice? Yea it wasn’t a bad movie but it’s the reason they stopped these one-offs. Rogue One is legitimately good

Calling something “fun” doesn’t mean it’s good. Even in your list of good things you have to include things that aren’t good because so little exists.

2

u/--_-Deadpool-_-- Jun 15 '24

I'm still curious about what content makes the majority of the SW:EU "trash"

Care to expand?

2

u/UncontrolledLawfare Jun 15 '24

In general? I already explained the overall problem with Gulp Shitto. Overexplaining everything, everyone is important. Retconning, reviving characters, overusing locations.

1

u/--_-Deadpool-_-- Jun 15 '24

So fan service and expanding character lore is not something you're interested in. That's fair.

But I'm still confused as to how there can be "A LOT more" content beyond what I've previously mentioned while simultaneously having "so little" content to reference.

1

u/UncontrolledLawfare Jun 16 '24

I’m not writing you a dissertation. I’ve explained my point plenty, if you’re still confused I can’t help you.

2

u/--_-Deadpool-_-- Jun 15 '24 edited Jun 15 '24

Right, Obi Wan. Also was good.

so little exists

You literally just said

A LOT more came out than just that.

So which is it? So little content exists that I have to include the bad ones. Or so much garbage content exists that the majority of content is garbage?

Even in your list of good things you have to include things that aren’t good because so little exists.

Yes, because you claimed the majority of content outside the original trilogy was trash. So I included all live action content to compare the good to the bad, to show that there's more good than bad. This isn't a hard concept to grasp.

But you're literally making two opposing statements in back to back to comments. So I really don't understand what opinion you're actually trying to convey, and I'm guessing that neither do you.