Just got back into dating after ending a 10 year relationship. Honestly, I still don’t even know what kind of man I want to be. I’m trying to figure myself out - how I want to show up and how to drop this “nice guy mask” I’ve been wearing for years where I over accommodate and soften what I feel so people don’t get uncomfortable, something that I have graciously gifted from my past relationship unfortunately.
For the past 2 months, I’ve been talking to this girl. We went on a few dates, even spent a full weekend together for a concert she invited me to. I really like her - not just “crushing,” but genuinely enjoy being around her. After the concert, I sent her a heartfelt message saying I liked her, that I wasn’t rushing anything, I just wanted clarity and to know her better.
She replied saying she might fall under the aromantic spectrum, that she has trouble telling platonic from romantic feelings, and that she’s scared of leading me on and hurting me. She did told me on our second date, but since the last text I opened up, she said she wants to try with me but now she’s been slower to reply and more distant. I felt like I should've done it in person.
Where she was mostly available to chat even for a bit now, she doesn't even reply at all during the day. She has grown even more distant by the day. I tried to find reasons due to my plegmatic side, but it doesn't add up. From her replies "I am not on my phone that much", "I'm very busy right now" while she was able to reply to me before even not timely but she put in the time to - it makes me really happy to get to know someone from the little interactions.
I know and I feel I'm also at fault. I treated it as a relationship when its not, so the way I speak to her is different.
"I am here with you, we will work on this together"
where I could've went a bit more romantic and show what I actually want rather than generalizing it:
"I can't say for sure that I understand what you are going through, but I would love to be in your journey every step of the way. We will find out new things together."
This morning I sent:
Hey, I know its early in the morning but this has been on my mind. I screwed it up before. I’d really like to make it up to you if you’ll let me. Are you open to meet me this weekend?
I am waiting on her reply, but I don't want to stuck in a Limbo - she said yes before on taking a chance but at the same time feels like she isn't putting the effort. Part of me is scared I’ve already pushed her away by being too direct. Part of me is proud I finally spoke my truth.
I’m struggling because:
- I carry this fear of being “not enough” or “too much"
- I want to respect her space but I also don’t want to just sit here overthinking.
- I don’t want to lose her, but I also don’t want to stay stuck if she’s not interested.
- I miss the fun and light conversations we had before I got serious.
I feel lost - how do you keep being honest about what you want without scaring someone away? How do you know when to hold on vs. let go? My friends have been saying to just move on but I don't know why its hard for me - my friends keep telling me that I have a "servile" behaviour.
This overthinking is slowly making me crazy. I don't know if it is normal, I just know I need to get it off my chest.
I appreciate any comments even though it might be the cold hard truth.
Thank you for reading this wall of text.