r/europe 8h ago

Irish protester ‘repeatedly punched in the face by police’ during Gaza protest in Berlin

https://www.independent.ie/irish-news/irish-protester-repeatedly-punched-in-the-face-by-police-during-gaza-protest-in-berlin/a249856773.html
1.5k Upvotes

682 comments sorted by

500

u/FinnMcKoolio 7h ago

What is an Irish Woman doing in Germany duurrrr? We're in the European Union you morons! Cant you think for a second before typing?

197

u/Particular_Bug0 6h ago

Wouldn't be surprised if the people writing that aren't from the EU

92

u/WumbleInTheJungle 6h ago

You'd be surprised how many Brits think the whole of Ireland is part of the UK! 

→ More replies (4)

7

u/Shadow_Gabriel Romania 4h ago

So what, we have a federalized EU when it's convenient but keep the dirty Easterners out of Schengen?

→ More replies (3)

281

u/Elegant-Chemical4466 5h ago

Facts of the matter:

  • protest was peaceful
  • protest was not registered
  • police repeatedly punched protester in the face

My unsolicited opinion: punching a singular protester in the face is not an appropriate reaction to a protestor in an unregistered protest. Some might even say it’s an unlawful reaction.

585

u/estrellaente 7h ago

I can't believe how many people justify police violence in this post. If we changed countries, would they still defend them?

279

u/Rare_Opportunity2419 7h ago

Lots of people with authoritarian mindsets. They're not against jackboots stamping on the necks of dissenters if the right people are wearing them.

186

u/bediaxenciJenD81gEEx 6h ago

Bots + this subreddit hates ireland

76

u/Lazy-Common4741 5h ago

One of the most pro-EU countries that happens to get shit on relentlessly here

19

u/MeggaMortY 5h ago

What, really? Why?

41

u/panzgap Yemen 5h ago

Hasbara mindslaves

9

u/MeggaMortY 5h ago

It's sad that it's working because every sort of messaging I've seen so far from that country has sounded like a poorly-written teenager's plea.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

17

u/ziadabdelsalam Ireland 5h ago

It's too easy to do it with bots

→ More replies (1)

10

u/lasttimechdckngths Europe 5h ago edited 5h ago

Some of those people love cops and cop violence like there's no tomorrow, unless it's some populist right-wing demonstration that gets touched a bit - while some even wouldn't mind that as they're 'centrists™'.

8

u/InformationNew66 5h ago

This is typical reddit nowdays. Radically supporting authority and politicians.

22

u/Dazzling_Lobster3656 7h ago

Yes

This is acceptable in Russia, turkey Serbia but ....Germany no way

38

u/PutnikTZ 7h ago

Wtf? This is not acceptable in Russia, Serbia, Turkey or Germany. Should not be acceptable anywhere in the World.

24

u/spooky-Dragonfruit1 7h ago

Haven’t you seen police brutality in cases of those countries? They’re beating the shit out of people without any consequences, so I’d say it’s acceptable (from government’s side) as there were no cops prosecuted for such actions.

10

u/wizamoku 6h ago

And that’s wrong. They should be prosecuted. But because their governments aren’t democratic, they won’t be. And I hope you’re not insinuating Germany should become undemocratc like those countries.

8

u/spooky-Dragonfruit1 6h ago

That is my exact point. And I am not insinuating it, though I have seen German police beating peaceful protesters while German politicians are talking about police brutality in Serbia and Georgia. So quite cynical, don’t you think?

Now of course, I understand Germany has issues with immigrants and their refusal to assimilate, but I thought peaceful protests are basic right in democracies.

105

u/justadubliner Ireland 7h ago

It been the norm by German police against pro Palestinian protesters for many years. They beat them up and arrest them. Even anti zionist Jews get the same treatment.

Germany wants to ensure the Palestinians continue to pay the price for Germanys historical sins which explains why they are more brutal than any other European country towards such protesters.

→ More replies (43)

11

u/Celmeno 6h ago

Always has been acceptable in Germany.

3

u/lasttimechdckngths Europe 5h ago

Who even told you that in the first place, lmao.

1

u/umonoz 7h ago

You’re wrong. In Turkey this fucking nazi at least would be sacked. Our cops prefer batons to legs and small gas capsules.  Not bc the sake of justice ofc. They would be afraid of public backlash.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/TESThrowSmile 6h ago

I can't believe how many people justify police violence in this post. If we changed countries, would they still defend them?

Honestly, as a non-white American, the thing I've noticed from the European-centric subs is the subtle, subconscious, white-supremecy talking points pushed out and openly supported on these subs.

I support Western Values, but im starting to realize at the top of Western Values is white supremacy. Yikes !

→ More replies (27)

99

u/whooo_me 5h ago

An angry policeman isn’t a policeman. He’s a thug in uniform.

And that’s not policing. It’s vanilla assault.

339

u/vandrag Ireland 8h ago

The bot farms were ready for this one. Go go power brigaders.

129

u/OneGoodAssSyllabus 6h ago

“Brutalizing protestors is fine, actually”

66

u/masiakasaurus Europe 6h ago

"This is just how normal demonstrations are handled"

2

u/Agile_Competition_28 5h ago

A wojak would go great right in here

7

u/recursivereader 7h ago

Protests should be a space for peaceful demonstration and dialogue, not violence. It's important for authorities to reassess their approach to ensure people can protest safely....... The use of excessive force by police only fuels further anger and division.

1

u/Low_Mistake_7748 6h ago

Fascinating how it's always bot farms when the narrative isn't aligned with the sub :)

73

u/onarainyafternoon Dual Citizen (American/Hungarian) 6h ago

Huh? Yeah, that's exactly how it works. If the narrative shifts drastically from what it would normally be in this sub, then it's obviously being manipulated by outside forces. Your comment is so weird.

33

u/CthulhusSoreTentacle Ireland 6h ago

It's a two month old account with a generic randomised name "Something_Something_Numbers". Not saying all users like this are bots/trolls, but there's a strong correlation.

3

u/reddit-is-a-cunt 4h ago

Thank god thats not my naming scheme, thought I was a meant to be botting for a sec

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Doyoulikemyjorts 5h ago

Is this not perfectly on brand for this sub tho? It's one notch down from r/world news when it comes to Palestine.

14

u/CalligoMiles Utrecht (Netherlands) 6h ago

The point is that bot farms aren't unique to the side you dislike. Or did we already forget how the whole Scottish independence movement fell silent when the Iranian internet got blown up, or the absolute piles of evidence on how they support absolutely anything and everything vaguely aligned against Israel and the West with the online narratives they push?

Just because you agree with a sentiment doesn't mean it can't also be heavily pushed by bots all the time.

3

u/Bhdrbyr Turkey 6h ago

The point is that bot farms aren't unique to the side you dislike.

Opposing police brutality is being on some kind of side now? Oh well it looks like the right side to be on then lol

7

u/CalligoMiles Utrecht (Netherlands) 6h ago edited 5h ago

Well, if you insist on being dense - even when you're objectively right on a point, that sentiment is still being amplified and exaggerated by bot farms too as part of the broader sides in the conflict it relates to. And Iran and its proxies have been doing that a whole lot bigger and better than Israel over the entire past decade if not longer.

Pointing it out as if it only happens when you disagree with what they're pushing just displays your lack of critical thinking and inability to form thoughts beyond what your tribe has declared good and evil.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/lasttimechdckngths Europe 5h ago

We all know that there are enough dedicated scum to bring in hordes, but it's hardly deniable that there are bots when it comes to this particular issue at least.

3

u/Nachtwacht12 6h ago

The fact that those comments get to stay on top says enough about the alleged bot usage. It doesn't exist, and they don't like people have different opinions, and will be elitarian while suppressing those opinions and then be surprised theres a civil war in a few years

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] 8h ago

[deleted]

24

u/ZestycloseGur8108 7h ago edited 7h ago

You're the bot, in every thread defending Israel and attacking protesters. So far you got 9 of the 88 comments in this one.

edit: The guy blocked me, so I can't respond to anything he writes. I would say people should look at his comment history, but he hides that for obvious reasons.

→ More replies (5)

17

u/Either-Detective-479 7h ago

I don’t understand, are you like pro Ukraine, anti Palestine? Imperialism is fine as long as it’s not your country?

-1

u/sjedinjenoStanje USA/Croatia 7h ago

I am. I'm against the entities that initiated wars against their neighbors that they seek to destroy because they don't consider them a legitimate country. Hamas started a war to destroy Israel, and Russia started a war to destroy Ukraine.

It's really not all that hard unless you have a hard-on for Israel, which about half of Europeans and most Arabs/Muslims do for obvious reasons.

1

u/Weirdo9495 Europe 7h ago

Same here. Although i do not justify the police violence in question.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

5

u/mcchicken16 7h ago

on high speed today

You have like 20+ comments in a 45minute old thread.

-26

u/vomicyclin Berlin (Germany) 7h ago

"everyone with another opinion than me has to be a bot."

Your bubble is showing...

28

u/Toums95 7h ago

Look at any polls. People tend to be quite fed up about Israel and their government stance about it. I think you are the one in a bubble buddy

→ More replies (29)

5

u/vandrag Ireland 7h ago

Oh you sweet summer child.

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (2)

183

u/samuel199228 8h ago edited 7h ago

Did the officer really need to punch the protester in the face should be sacked for that and charged for assault.

Just no need to do it

41

u/LJA170 6h ago edited 5h ago

Battery, or whatever the German equivalent may be. Mind you, it’s entirely in keeping with the state’s current views so the judge would probably award the officer with a medal instead.

96

u/AlwaysReadyGo British & Jordanian 7h ago

Of course not. I watched the video, he clearly wanted to punch her. He’s a violent man in the right position to get away with it. Brutalising protesters for the ‘right reasons,’ given how strongly Germany opposes justice for Palestinians.

4

u/[deleted] 7h ago

[deleted]

27

u/Rare_Walk_4845 7h ago

oh wow verbal abuse, better get to punching. if only there were some other way to detain a perp

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

60

u/valtarri 7h ago

Europe is starting to willfully give away its rights to free speech, peaceful protest and privacy, and we're just supposed to take it and "comply' with these baseless new laws that equate denouncing a genocide to supporting terrorism and antisemitism, whilst giving total immunity to cops to beat the shit out of people? I'm all for proportionate use of law and order, but a good chunk of morons on here are just welcoming the rise of violent police states with open arms.

198

u/Rare_Opportunity2419 7h ago

So many bootlickers in this subreddit.

→ More replies (47)

80

u/Bonoisapox 8h ago edited 7h ago

Apparently an appropriate response to being verbally assaulted

125

u/2beHero 7h ago

If verbal assaults make you feel threatened, then you are a baby not a police officer and should get a more appropriate job

53

u/Bonoisapox 7h ago

Just fucking violent bullies, it’s a young girl too

49

u/Rare_Opportunity2419 7h ago

Oh yeah, violence is definitely justified by mean words. \s

19

u/Bonoisapox 7h ago

I’m glad you marked as sarcasm as others don’t seem to get it

11

u/Rare_Opportunity2419 7h ago

It's literally what they believe.

→ More replies (5)

61

u/meckez 8h ago

A punch in the face is not an appropriate response of the police to verbal assault. At least not in Germany.

35

u/Fast-Presence-2004 7h ago

It usually isn’t. You don’t see police doing this often, not even at fast right rallies. It’s mostly when it gives to Palestine. Palestinians have been dehumanized for so long, people don’t see it anymore.

27

u/Dazzling_Lobster3656 7h ago

Big strong police Only punch the women?

14

u/justadubliner Ireland 7h ago

German police have been beating up Pro Palestinian protesters for years. Even long before the genocide. They are renowned for it.

→ More replies (2)

58

u/Clean-Potential7647 6h ago

Welcome to the police state Germany…

20

u/X-Jet 5h ago

Imagine whats gonna happen after chat control goes online, eesh
And people are mocking russia for being autoritarian hellhole.

44

u/StinkyHotFemcel 8h ago

if this is what he feels safe to do in public imagine what he does at home to his wife

→ More replies (5)

158

u/MasterSafety374 8h ago

An iconic duo: Germany and state violence against dissenters.

17

u/genshermansghosthost 7h ago

Right? I can’t see any downside to Germany, with a strong and growing fascist element, rearming itself and diverting funds to military, policing, and surveillance…

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] 7h ago edited 7h ago

[deleted]

32

u/luca3791 Denmark 7h ago

Verbal abuse of police doesn’t not constitute nor justify, punching a person in the face several times.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/ikarusproject Germany 7h ago

Which law allows violance against freedom of speech?

5

u/Jumpeee Finland 7h ago

Article 5 of the Grundgesetz isn't absolute. You have to comply with general laws. 

→ More replies (9)

16

u/syrian_samuel 7h ago

wtf does “offended physically” mean? She called them fat or something?

It’s quite telling if you feel repeatedly punching someone in the face because they said a bad word is reasonable

→ More replies (2)

12

u/Swictor 7h ago

You think police should assault people for being offensive and difficult?

6

u/koi88 7h ago

well done for the police here. nobody is above the law.

Beating protestors is not lawful here in Germany.

F*ck these cops, Berlin cops are worst now.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Svarcanum 8h ago

Add to that the way that cop styled his hair. Iconic in the worst sense.

→ More replies (7)

33

u/EcstaticYesterday605 Ireland 7h ago

They even brought the haircuts back this time.

138

u/Urzuck Italy 8h ago

She has more balls than all those little wankers put together.

→ More replies (23)

29

u/d_repz 6h ago

I hope that the Irish Government is on the case, this is NOT on!

35

u/Irish_cynic Ireland 5h ago

RTE news : Ambassador contacts German officials over protest assault

http://www.rte.ie/news/world/2025/0830/1530951-irish-gaza-berlin/

21

u/d_repz 5h ago

Thanks.

They broke her (Kathy) arm and punched her repeatedly for allegedly being "verbally aggressive"?! Disgusting. I saw the video the day before yesterday and if anything she was trying to back off! These police officers are an embarrassment to Germany and should be severely sanctioned!

Wishing Kathy a speedy recovery. 🙏🏾

34

u/DatewithanAce 8h ago

Comments here are disgusting.

4

u/XF_X 5h ago

This sub has been like this as long as I can remember. Sometimes some members show themselves.

1

u/manyworldsim 7h ago

That's a mirror

→ More replies (1)

39

u/bediaxenciJenD81gEEx 7h ago

The Germans back at it. 

→ More replies (8)

15

u/Jealous_Shower6777 6h ago

Pigs are pigs, no matter where

9

u/rainmouse 6h ago

Load comments. Sort by controversial. Strap yourselves in it's getting nasty. 

11

u/1980sumthing Türkiye Cumhuriyeti 7h ago

Same overdrive in mocking the girl over on x.

14

u/Junior_Ad585 5h ago

Free Palestine 

8

u/Sprat-Boy 7h ago

What again is an evidence for 1312

20

u/[deleted] 8h ago edited 6h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/Schnorch 5h ago

That won't happen.

You have to understand that in Germany there is no authority whose job it is to independently investigate possible police violence. Here, the police officer's colleagues are simply tasked with the “investigation.”

That's why German police officers are pretty much protected from prosecution, which is confirmed by practically every statistic available on the subject. There are other factors at play here, such as prosecutors who want to stay on good terms with the police because they work with them, etc., but that would be going too far now.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/manyworldsim 7h ago

Why does gender matter? Remember we're all equal right? Right?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] 8h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

13

u/[deleted] 8h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/vomicyclin Berlin (Germany) 7h ago

"despite repeated orders” to leave the area, O’Brien “refused to comply and insulted verbally and offended physically, several police officers. There is clear evidence for verbal insults shouted by this individual, ranging from calling officers ‘genocide supporters’, ‘f\*king Nazis’ and ‘you should be ashamed of yourselves – there are babies starving’ among many more statements made.*"

8

u/gobocork 5h ago

Oh no, did the words hurt their feelings? How dreadful! She very obviously did not assault the cops, which is why they used the very tenuous phrasing: "offended physically". You better believe, if she had actually assaulted anyone that is what they would have said.

30

u/SilentBass75 7h ago

She did not assault the cop so.... she said some mean words

→ More replies (4)

8

u/Far_Advertising1005 6h ago

Complete and pathetic bootlicking from you.

“She called him a meanie word! Of course it’s fine that he violently assaulted her!” He’s a pathetic baby who should be fired immediately if he can’t handle being (rightfully) insulted

6

u/Dazzling_Lobster3656 7h ago

3

u/vomicyclin Berlin (Germany) 7h ago

so...?

Insult an police officer in Germany as a "nazi" and you will find out. This "everybody with another opinion than me is a nazi"-nonsense will get you consequences here.

16

u/Sexul_constructivist 6h ago

If you called me a nazi, and i started beating you in the face, would you call the police on me?

1

u/Detozi Ireland 4h ago

Of course they would. Right after they finished balling their eyes out.

21

u/noorderlijk 7h ago

If a cop behaves like a nazi, then he deserves to be called like that. We fought a war to get rid of such thugs, you know. Nazis and Gestapo like police have no place in our world.

8

u/biggronklus 6h ago

If you call a cop a Nazi for clearing a protest and they beat you senseless they’re kinda acting like a Nazi lmao

→ More replies (2)

1

u/qwq1792 5h ago

If a woman called you a nazi you would punch her? The f*ck is wrong with you?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

-8

u/Svorky Germany 8h ago edited 7h ago

If you go to an illegal protest and then push back against police trying to remove you, you might get punched.

So nothing will happen. Legally they have a lot of leeway to "break resitance against Police measures". Use of force is valid here, it would just be a question of a judge judging it excessive or not. But it's almost certainly just not excessive enough to get police into trouble here.

As a bonus tip for her, I would not pursue legal action. She pushed him first, and police will (in this case likely successfully) countersue.

26

u/Dazzling_Lobster3656 7h ago

Right to protest is as german as Bier

11

u/justadubliner Ireland 7h ago

Not for pro Palestinian protesters. Even anti Zionist Jews get this treatment. Germany police have been beating up and arresting pro Palestinian protesters for many years. Germany wants to ensure the Palestinians continue to pay the price for Germanys sins. It's why they are second only to the US in providing the genociders with the means to commit the genocide.

4

u/Habitatti 5h ago

The real kicker is that Israel wasn’t even founded for holocaust surviors, but for rich ethnic Jews (clarifying as religion has little to do with Zionism). Countless of less fortunate Jews were rejected from Israeli citizenship after the holocaust, namely Polish and Ukranian Jews.

2

u/justadubliner Ireland 5h ago

Ethiopian Jews also didn't get a rousing welcome. Wasn't it as recent as decade ago they were forcing contraception on Ethiopians?! Truth is Israel was always going to end up as a brutal apartheid state. The type of character who believes they have the right to disposessess and subjugate native people in this day and age was always going to result in a country that resembles MAGA on steroids.

1

u/justadubliner Ireland 5h ago

And they refused Ugandan Jews apparently but not white South African Jewish converts. Shades of the current Trumpistan attitude to refugees. https://www.reddit.com/r/IsraelCrimes/s/ra2MOqSlXG

4

u/Svorky Germany 7h ago

You have the right to protest, police have the power to order you to disperse, you have the right to take it to the courts.

Do you see who strayed from the law where.

22

u/Dazzling_Lobster3656 7h ago

Yes no argument there

There is "proportional response required"

This is not that

1

u/UNOvven Germany 7h ago

Yeah, the police. You do not have a right to punch people in the face, you especailly dont have the right to do that with banned quartz sand gloves.

1

u/Sea-Bend-5914 6h ago

This is how it started in Russia. Everyone has the right to protest. But the police also had the power to order the people to disperse. Everyone who didn't like it had the right to complain to the courts. Now we know how this story ended.

1

u/Svorky Germany 6h ago

Right ok. Name a country where police don't have that power.

3

u/ZestycloseBeach5946 7h ago

As per Germanys own laws force must be “moderate and proportionate”. Is repeatedly punching a woman in the face for shoving you proportionate ?

I agree she laid hands on a police officer so if she got cuffed and removed I’d have to no sympathy but getting concussed is excessive.

8

u/the_Dachshund 7h ago

Well it seems like you haven’t seen the video…

And it’s part of the job to control yourself. If all it needs for you to get that violent because of a little push, then you are wrong in your job.

4

u/UNOvven Germany 7h ago

The protest was legal, the police had no right to attempt to remove anyone, he was using quartz sand gloves which are banned, and the use of force was excessive. This is probably one of the easiest lawsuits to win in a while. The police is already getting into trouble for constantly trying to illegally stop protests.

2

u/Fluffy-Republic8610 6h ago

A little push back to get a shield out of your face is not violence. Are you suggesting a protester should move as if they are on wheels? It's not pushing forward into a defended place. It's just standing your ground on the public street, making a protest. The public street belongs to the public. The police are not the owners of the street. They are there to help secure the street for people. This protest was being attended by some other the people they are there to protect.

It's supposed to be noisy. It can sometimes not be applied for in advance. There is a genocide on. We have to show authority that if they dont act we are capable of causing disturbance.

None of that allows authority to punch you in the face, twice.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

12

u/An22x 8h ago

peaceful Palestine protesters

despite repeated orders” to leave the area, O’Brien “refused to comply and insulted verbally and offended physically, several police officers. There is clear evidence for verbal insults shouted by this individual, ranging from calling officers ‘genocide supporters’, ‘f**king Nazis’ and ‘you should be ashamed of yourselves – there are babies starving’ among many more statements made.

🙃

30

u/Blueskyways 7h ago

Mean words are a green light for police to beat the hell out of someone apparently.  

32

u/FrogOnABus Ireland 7h ago

Words = Violence! Is it still 2016??

→ More replies (3)

74

u/2beHero 7h ago

Again: if you, as a police officer, feel threatened by someone's shouting and respond with escalation, then you are a baby with a weak nervous system and should not be in a position of authority lol.

1

u/An22x 7h ago

Yes. And if you can't protest without seeking fights with the police officers, you should stay the fuck at home or deal with the consequences.

16

u/Sexul_constructivist 6h ago

Of you assault somebody, because he called you names, you will go to jail for battery. Why do we hold police to a lower standard than regular civilians?

→ More replies (4)

8

u/polypolip 6h ago

Yes, protest by going to cemetery and lying yourself in the grave, quietly.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/bigdoinkloverperson 7h ago

Police are in function and should never resort to physical violence based on verbal abuse. If you can't do that don't become a cop lmao and you'd be chirping differently if the protestor was doing son for a cause you agree with typical hypocrisy

9

u/An22x 6h ago

I literally agreed. Jesus Christ. Y'all are reading whatever the fuck you want.

6

u/bigdoinkloverperson 6h ago

You didn't, saying if you're looking for fights (i.e. In this context protesting I mean that's already says a lot using the word fight) with police you should stay home that implied you think the consequences are justified or at least normal.

Maybe learn to write before accusing others of not being able to read

2

u/An22x 6h ago

I agreed that this cop shouldn't be in a position of authority and then you jump at me all mad telling me that this cop shouldn't be a cop. And somehow I'm the one that can't read here? Holy fuck.

3

u/ValeteAria 7h ago

The police is getting paid to do their job. If they cant do it they shouldnt be at the job.

If some words make you assault someone, then you are not fit to be a cop. It is that simple. Protesters are there to protest. In their free time. They aint getting paid.

The police officer is there because he is getting paid. So do your fucking job.

5

u/An22x 7h ago

Exactly, they're doing their job. And their job was to clear the area. The protesters had Platzverweis, so the police had to make them move to a different location. If you can't understand that the cops were just doing their job, but instead go out of your way to insult them and seek physical confrontation while ignoring their order, I have zero sympathy for you. It's literally called fck around and find out. 

6

u/ValeteAria 6h ago

Exactly, they're doing their job. And their job was to clear the area.

You can also clear the area by shooting at everyone. Do you think thats a smart idea?

The protesters had Platzverweis, so the police had to make them move to a different location.

Right and you can do that in ways that dont require punching someone until their nose starts bleeding. What happend to using a baton against their thigh or other body parts?

If you can't understand that the cops were just doing their job, but instead go out of your way to insult them and seek physical confrontation while ignoring their order, I have zero sympathy for you. It's literally called fck around and find out. 

Their job is to clear out the area. Not to beat up citizens. You can tell someone to leave your house without beating them up. I understand that it might be difficult to understand for people who arent civilized.

The police is supposed to clear out the area. Not turn it into fight club. They are taught how to clear an area. They have batons. You can use those batons or push people. You use them on non-lethal areas. You dont start punching people in the face. How is that supposed to make them leave the area? You punch someone in the face to hurt them.

I dont care for your sympathy. I highly doubt you got space for sympathy in that brain of yours. But sure, just dont complain when life hits you with the find out phase.

→ More replies (2)

-1

u/lifeandtimes89 Ireland 7h ago

And if you can't protest without seeking fights with the police officers

Bruh what?

Seeking fights? Where in the video is she or anyone "seeking" fights?

Its a protest, a legally given right

14

u/An22x 7h ago

If a cop tells you to move because you have freaking Platzverweis, but you repeatedly decide to move towards them while repeatedly insulting them, that is seeking fights in my books.

And no, there is no right to protest wherever the fuck you want. Protests need to be angemeldet und you have certain routes that you need to stick to, in order not to obstruct businesses, traffic etc, which these protesters willingly violated, so the cops Had to make them move.

6

u/Lefaid US in Netherlands 6h ago

As you can see, it is a very valid strategy as well. Why listen to a cop when provoking them will lead to more moral outrage in your favour?

4

u/An22x 6h ago

Yup, and a lot of commenters even take pride in that.

"Of course a protest should have inconveniences! Cause all the inconveniences!! We can violate laws as much as we want, but then we'll cry hysterically when a cop turns out to be a human instead of a flawless robot 🤭"

1

u/lifeandtimes89 Ireland 6h ago

Lol I'm all for protesting as long as it doesn't bother me or anyone else, sure they may as well go protest in a field then.

If it wasn't for protesting then there would be no change. But sure enjoy being genocide enablers. Nothing in this video gives that man the right to punch this woman repeatedly in the face

→ More replies (2)

58

u/elPerroAsalariado 7h ago

If a protest doesn't inconvenience anyone... Who would ever listen to it?

Have you seen the video? She was repeatedly hit in the face without a violent response from her side

Mean words

Ah yeah, that poor cop

-2

u/An22x 7h ago

I've seen the video, yes. The cops told them to leaves the area because they have Platzverweis. She didn't move. Cops continued to tell them they need to move in that direction. She didn't move. Cops tried to push the protestors in that direction. She literally moved towards the cops seeking confrontation. Obviously she then said some of the various insults that you can find in the press statement, so a cop punched her. And she continued to move towards them. Like bruh.

7

u/elPerroAsalariado 7h ago

Have you seen any protest ever?

Are you implying what she was doing was either violent or that she had it coming?

-1

u/Koizito 7h ago

What do their boots taste like?

1

u/An22x 7h ago

If you go into a protest with this mindset, no wonder you end up getting punched.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Detozi Ireland 4h ago

Where is the assault in there? Or are you just a very precious person?

4

u/SwolePalmer Vatican City 5h ago

You should arch your back a little more if you’re going to do all this boot licking, boy. Come on, you can do it!

1

u/TheManlyManperor 7h ago

"Oh no, this woman is calling me out for defending genocide and acting like the Nazis we pretend we've outgrown! I have to punch her to prove her right!" Isn't really the argument you think it is.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Honest-Cantaloupe230 8h ago

where is video?

43

u/Urzuck Italy 8h ago

50

u/koi88 7h ago

I see tons of unlawful behaviour from the police. At 1:30, police are pushing the protesters though it's obvious they can't move faster.

This may cause a panic and must be avoided, especially as minors can be seen in the crowd (e.g. at 0:40, gets violently pushed as well).

Here we can see the policeman acts without reason: https://youtu.be/8SUln5weESQ?feature=shared&t=92

This guy is clearly unfit for his job and needs to be removed.

Though the real problem is Berlin's mayor.

→ More replies (19)

1

u/FrogOnABus Ireland 7h ago

We need to do something about Germany: Part 3.

5

u/umonoz 5h ago

And they are arming again with a far right government in the horizon. I would not like to be Poland right now for sure

4

u/Mitrakov 5h ago

Ireland's prime minster sent his condolences to the German Embassy when Hitler died

whatcha gonna do, lol

→ More replies (2)

4

u/iLoveCoachQ 6h ago

If we’ve learned anything from history the side the German government is on is always wrong

5

u/EquipmentAdorable982 6h ago

FUCK THE POLICE

A----C----A----B

0

u/Svarcanum 8h ago

That cop had a particular hairdo. I wonder what it reminds me of…

0

u/soalone34 5h ago

Germany’s position is that what israel is doing is wrong but so is protesting it.

-1

u/[deleted] 8h ago edited 8h ago

[deleted]

28

u/Toums95 8h ago edited 8h ago

Maybe she lives in Germany. I am Italian, I live in Hamburg and have participated to protests

→ More replies (9)

14

u/ignore_my_name 8h ago

What the hell is an Argentinian doing in a European subreddit

1

u/[deleted] 8h ago

[deleted]

7

u/mikelium 8h ago

You walked into a foreign subreddit and started stirring shit.

→ More replies (1)

-50

u/Artistic-Bass3477 7h ago

What the fuck are irish protestors doing in germany lmao

This seems weirdly organized

67

u/Dazzling_Lobster3656 7h ago

EU citizen

Freedom of movement to work/live travel....

→ More replies (2)

94

u/EcstaticYesterday605 Ireland 7h ago

Irish living in Germany, Germans live in Ireland. Is it really difficult to get in a time where EU citizens have freedom of movement?

→ More replies (9)

23

u/_Hiugans_ 7h ago

As an EU citizen I can move, work, and yes, protest in any EU country of my choosing so long as I follow any applicable laws.

Many EU citizens live and work in countries other than the one where they were born hence it is also true that those citizens can protest in other countries.

It’s not weird or out of place, it’s perfectly natural and requires no actual organization other than the protest’s organization to comply with local laws.

7

u/_Druss_ Ireland 6h ago

Why are polish people living in other European countries?? 🫏

→ More replies (6)

8

u/BlackBaron44 7h ago

Standing for their rights with the occasional left thrown in for good measure.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/redditpromoteracism 5h ago

Are they going back to WW2 Germany now?

-8

u/EcstaticYesterday605 Ireland 7h ago

Einsatzgrupen would be proud.

-22

u/GlobalFriendship5855 7h ago

The comments here are incredibly disgusting. There's this one police officer who may or may not have acted correctly (which is for a judge to decide, not for randompeople on the internet who know nothing about the case other than the headline) and all of a sudden Germany is a "Nazi country" which "endangers all of Europe" and "shouldn't be allowed to rearm".

Please name me one country on earth without police violence. So by that logic every country is now a Nazi country, right?

3

u/Kunjunk Ireland Spain 5h ago

Bro's been asleep for the last couple of years.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Fluffy-Republic8610 6h ago

This is not a one off, this is part of a pattern of official discrimination. The Berlin authorities have a problem with people who protest for justice for Palestine.

5

u/ikarusproject Germany 6h ago

Not just Palestine. Berlin Police is has a tough response to all forms of protest against the government. Democratic Protest? Not when it bothers the politicians in Berlin. How dare you to criticize a democratically elected government? This is part of an increasing authoritarianism since the 90ies.

5

u/Fluffy-Republic8610 6h ago

Thank you for the insight. I was losing hope that I would find a voice from germany on here that wasn't just defending the Berlin police in this case.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (11)

3

u/Sea-Bend-5914 5h ago

They should start with not beating protestors.

3

u/Wonderful-Plastic-44 7h ago

Nazi Germans mad

4

u/GlobalFriendship5855 6h ago

Everyone who is not extrem leftist is a Nazi and everyone who is not extremeright wing js a communist. At least according to strangers on the Internet.

2

u/truthertz2 4h ago

You seem like a well informed individual, unfortunately your well informed on how German jackboots taste

→ More replies (2)