r/eurovision • u/thrvisionary • 10h ago
Song Ranking Ranking ESC 2025 countries that internally selected songs and whether or not they should keep the format.
Rubric–
How good was the song this year?
Did their previous national final attempt produce anything good?
Has internal selection served them well?
France: 6/7. They’ve done well with their internal selections. All the artists were great and had pretty good songs with good placings this decade (except for Évidement, but it didn’t deserve it). I think they don’t need to switch to a national final, but they will probably produce a good song regardless (we have 2021 to prove it). Plus, Maman is just a good song.
Switzerland: 5/7. On one hand we have Zoë Më and Nemo finishing top 10 (Zoë finishing 10th without any public vote points and Nemo finishing first), and on the other, we have consistant nul points from the public vote. They shouldn’t switch to a national final considering how the resulting songs were usually non-qualifying dumpster fires.
United Kingdom: 5/7. They produce constant nul points, but their songs are usually good (in my opinion; much better than what they produced before). I think if they went back to the national finals that produced crybaby, teenage life, and hundreds of more songs blander than british food, they would get even worse results. The internal selection has produced Britain’s best result in years (Space Man by Sam Ryder), so I think they are better off without it. Plus, Remember Monday far outclasses all of the pre-2020 examples, and did not deserve the nul points.
Czechia: 5/7. Kiss Kiss Goodbye was ridiculously good, but didn’t get a good result. However, it makes sense for Czechia to cancel their national final since the production quality isn’t great and they probably don’t have the budget for it. However, their national finals in the past have produced good results before, and I don’t see a reason it can’t again. Since this is their first year, I’m curious to see what’s next in store.
Australia 6/7. With the exception of recent years, Australia has produced some of the greatest ESC songs within recent memory through an internal selection. Their national finals haven’t led to great results (of course they’ve only had 3 and one of them was in 2020, and yes I know 2019 had a top 10 result), and I think they’re better off with their internal selection. As for this year, the song was pretty good, but I think it missed out because the public disliked its sexual content. But because of Voyager and Dami Im and Guy Sebastian, it proves that they’re competent in selecting a good act.
Netherlands 7/7. They produced Arcade, Europapa, C’est la Vie, and others without a national final. Their national finals have lead to less than good results, and I think that they should just keep the internal selection.
Austria 7/7. They’ve only sent good acts with internal selection, and screwed up every single one of their national selections. Wasted Love is great, the Makemakes are not, and the only times they’ve won this century is through internal selection. Keep it for the sake of our eardrums.
Cyprus 4/7. They have sent Eleni once and have been desperately trying to get it back through staging alone. Theo Evan’s staging was great, but his vocals were so weak. The national finals and internal selections rarely select something that scores, so it gets a middle of the road score.
Georgia 4/7. The same goes for Cyprus, but worse. They haven’t had a decent result after 2010, and to me, the music scene has changed so dramatically that it’s unrealistic to recreate it using that exact same formula. They did bad with both types of selections and Freedom was terrible, so let’s move on.
Azerbaijan 3/7. Haven’t had a good result (outlier being 2019) since 2013. However, I do know that this is mostly because the power ballad phase in ESC is over. Their recent results are pretty bad, and while I liked Run with You as a studio version, the live version was just so bad. They should bring back the national final to see if they can maybe bring something good in.
That should be it. I might have missed a country, but I don’t think i did. Overall, I think internal selections are usually good for countries, but if the internal selection team is tone deaf, it’s a major issue