As per the title, I have a new student that started with me a few weeks back.
He can play some basic chords and was clearly not too bad...many years ago. He's very rusty and holds the guitar in a way that is likely to end with a carpel tunnel op.
He wants to learn an incredibly complex piece of classical music. I'm fine with that, I learned the piece and it's a nice bit of music.
I put together some exercises that will help him achieve this, some are a little basic from where he used to be some years ago, but they go some way to correcting his hold and reacquainting him with some chords and fingerstyle techniques.
He phoned me at the weekend to say he doesn't want to do the exercises and just wants to learn the piece of music.
With all respect due, he's miles away from being able to play this piece, and I told him that as diplomatically as I could, but he's insisting that's what we work on.
I fear that if I were to actually do this, he'll damage himself, first and foremost, and secondly, will become dissapointed and dissolutioned when he finds he can't play it.
I mean, I've been playing 40 years, and it took me over an hour to get it right. This is not something that's going to be an easy win.
What do I do here?
In the past, students have asked for similar but have all understood their limitations and the reasoning of the exercises produced by me to get them to that goal.