r/handguns • u/jjones1987 • 2d ago

Would you rather

Post image

Have these two old friends, or one 3k 2011?

180 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

33 comments sorted by

22

u/winny9 2d ago

Keeping the 2. No doubt.

14

u/WorldGoneAway 2d ago

I like both, but the comp'd Beretta is my go-to.

30

u/Glockisthebest 2d ago

the beretta

5

u/SazedMonk 2d ago

What are the bigger differences between the PDP and Q4?

Both are gorgeous, but probably the Q4 for the grip feel.

3

u/Self-MadeRmry 1d ago

Mainly the slide. PDP just introduced new slide serrations and grip texture

3

u/New-Following5531 1d ago

That beretta is spicy!

5

u/Blitz1137 2d ago

Q4 SF is one of the most underrated carry options around. I'd keep these two personally.

3

u/NoSplit2488 2d ago

Love Walther but I’ll keep my CCW Glock G26 Gen4 and my Ruger LCP 380 Auto!

3

u/sexbob-mob 2d ago

Did you chop the slide release on the walther? Thinking about doing that to my pdp

3

u/skips_funny_af 1d ago

2 are better than 1…..ask my wife. Wait. Uhhhh i mean Go Lions

1

u/jjones1987 1d ago

Go lions!? You from Michigan?

2

u/Self-MadeRmry 1d ago

2 is better than 1, especially from these two solid contenders.

2

u/DasWheever 1d ago

Walther, please.

2

u/Lowcountry25 1d ago

Can't go wrong with either of these guns photographed here. I love the ODG scheme on both.

2

u/Kindly-Creme-1062 1d ago

100% those two

1

u/StinkyFeet4Days 1d ago

How do you like that comp on the beretta?

1

u/saudyl 1d ago

Id rather get a staccato c 👀

1

u/jjones1987 1d ago

I was looking at Jacob Grays TWC.

1

u/saudyl 1d ago

How do you intend to use said firearm?

1

u/jjones1987 1d ago

Range and training mostly. I use a couple Glocks for carry and I don’t think any 2011 would replace those. Maybe Stacattos new one would be a safe choice given Glock mags and being meant for duty. Then on the off chance I do want to switch, it’s made for that purpose and not just the range.

1

u/saudyl 1d ago

I gotcha. It would be a great range gun or even home defense gun! If you can tolerate the thickness of the grip it’s a fine carry piece. Reason I mentioned the staccato c is that it has a much thinner grip due to a different magazine design that makes it easier to carry. I carry mine every day! Safety shouldn’t be a concern with a 2011, just don’t drop em nose down of course

1

u/ReactionAble7945 1d ago

I have an old 92FS. I like it. I would be very curious ...

The Walther, I am less curious.

1

u/CDKJudoka 1d ago

The Beretta, all the way

1

u/poopypoopX 1d ago

I am a slut for OD green

1

u/No-Mammoth1045 1d ago

Hammer over striker all day

1

u/Fletchx 1d ago

The Beretta

1

u/Profit-Rude 1d ago

I’ve got both and they’re both amazing guns but Beretta wins in my book by a very very small margin.

2

u/HRyder62377 1d ago

I want a q4 sf so friggin bad. I must get one.

1

u/TriPalace 1d ago

Thats crazy those are the two handguns I have also. Was looking to just add a 2k11

2

u/Valhall22 13h ago

Like both, prefer the Walther. Nice look