r/judo Jul 06 '25

Other What’s your unpopular opinion on judo

Post image
262 Upvotes

394 comments sorted by

View all comments

9

u/judokalinker nidan Jul 06 '25

Hard randori is more effective for improving than the very light randori which many espouse.

7

u/Guivond Jul 06 '25

Wrestlers also have a big decline in their late 20s/early 30s. Kamaru Usman is one of many examples of wrestlers who's body fail due to the harmful training. He can't run but was a ufc champ who had to lean into striking.

If you visit the kodokan or other big clubs you will see old people who still train. Are they going to the Olympics? No but they can still do techniques properly and do randori.

I'd rather be able to train when I'm in my 50s/60s than not be able to run in my 30s.

1

u/judokalinker nidan Jul 06 '25

I still train with college wrestlers in their 40s and I think you are generalizing a bit too much.

2

u/Guivond Jul 06 '25

What outlet do they get to use to continually wrestle? In the US you don't find adult wrestling clubs that aren't wrestling for bjj. They aren't really wrestling in their 40s where I am, just bjj standup.

But if you look at ufc fighters MANY former high level wrestlers regress in it then turn to striking heavy games as they age for a reason.

1

u/judokalinker nidan Jul 06 '25

My MMA gym is in a wrestling heavy state and we do a lot of no gi. "just BJJ standup" isn't really relevant. The wrestlers there are anymore worn down than anyone I run into in judo.

14

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '25

Getting repeatedly injured improves nobody

5

u/Uchimatty Jul 06 '25

You get injured less with hard randori. A lot of studies across sports have shown injury rates are lower when training intensity matches competition intensity. The body conditions itself against its normal load. It’s when it’s exposed to a load it’s not used to that it breaks.

4

u/mondian_ Jul 07 '25

Link to the studies?

3

u/judokalinker nidan Jul 06 '25

Wrestlers never get good at wrestling

4

u/Azylim Jul 06 '25

I dont disagree, but the way I see it is a risk:reward ratio.

hard randori means fatigue and higher injury risk. injury and fatigue means time off training, or worse permanent injuries.

1 high heart rate randori round might improve you more than 1 medium or low heart rate round, but for every high heart rate round you can do like 10 medium heart rate rounds

1

u/Ill_Improvement_8276 Jul 06 '25

yeah i prefer decently hard randori

light is fine every now and then

1

u/Psychological-Will29 sankyu - I like footsies Jul 06 '25

based