r/movies Feb 17 '18

YMS - Black Panther

https://youtu.be/urBtAEObqoQ
323 Upvotes

952 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

66

u/Khaos3118 Feb 17 '18

Adum is really obsessed with perfecting what his personal view on every movie ever made is on a spectrum of 0 to 10. Everything then to him needs to be compared to Michael Haneke movies and anything that Charlie Kaufman is involved in. So 'mainstream' or anything 'for kids' needs to be on the same spectrum with art house or Foreign language films or documentaries.

48

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

62

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '18

[deleted]

6

u/PoonaniiPirate Feb 18 '18

As it should be. They are all movies. You cannot watch movies with the caveat that they are already bad so they should be on their own rating scale. That’s dumb. Just have a wider range of ratings that is acceptable. I consider 5/10 and 6/10 to be watchable movies but if you give that rating, people say you are not picking. Likenot including good movies as examples on your ratings u dercuts the importance of those good movies. If you take risks artistically and creatively, then execute successfully to create a good movie like a Haneke movie, you get the higher rating. You shouldn’t be given a pass as a “mindless movie” or a “superhero movie” and secure good ratings.

That’s just my personal opinion though. My rating scales for movies stays the same no matter which genre I watch. A movie like The Godfather deserves a higher rating than Wonder Woman to me and most people. If I apply the same nit picking attitude to The Godfather, I find very little. So I celebrate and enjoy, but also rate the movie higher. It’s so simple to me I wonder how people have difficulty.

2

u/Dark1000 Feb 18 '18

Agreed. There are brilliants kids' films, brilliant action film, brilliant genre films, etc. There's no reason to accept crap just because it's in a specific genre or for kids.