r/movies • u/AngryGardenGnomes • 21h ago
Review Jim Carrey's The Majestic (2001) - I was surprised by just how awful this sickly sweet movie is despite loving it as a kid
I love Jim Carrey. I love classic Hollywood. I find the McCarthy trials and the red scare really interesting. So this should have a been a blast of a rewatch. But it feels like director Frank Darabont, known more for intense hard hitting films, was trying too hard to move away from his formula by making such a sickly sweet movie.
It's about a screenwriter in 1950s Hollywood who gets blacklisted after attending a communist meeting. He then crashes his car. Suffers amnesia. Then finds himself in a dinky Californian town where he's mistaken for a cinema owner's son who died in the First World War.
It's just to so mawkish and dripping with sentimentality. Most of the writing really is cliche. I'd accuse it of being Oscar baity but I feel the subject matter is too light for that.
When Carrey is ejected from Hollywood, he spends a whole evening talking to a model of monkey rather than even trying to contact his girlfriend. Either those scenes were cut for pacing or they just wanted goofy scenes with Carrey. I imagine it was the latter.
Then when he's in the town, it becomes so kitschy. The romantic scenes with, the admittedly smoking hot, Laurie Holden feel very derivative where she all of a sudden gets the hiccups, leading up to their kiss on the top of a lighthouse. And the whole town following the two of them as they're walking away from a diner - just very silly.
Martin Landau is the one bright spark. Fantastic actor. So much emotion in those eyes.
The bad guy is very cliche. He's a government man hunting down Carrey and swats a fly as he's speaking about him. So on the nose.
The film starts to feel quite preachy as well. There's a black guy inexplicably living beneath The Majestic, a closed down theatre. He has a ponderously long monologue about being a war hero. And the audience is clearly meant to reflect on how wonderful the main characters are for allowing this black veteran live there in a time of heightened racism.
Real shame as I loved this movie when I was a child.