r/playstation Mar 31 '25

Discussion Which game has the better horses?

Post image
7.2k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

257

u/Bob69748742 Mar 31 '25

Like how much horses love to run into trees at high speeds

117

u/stuffeh Mar 31 '25

Usually, if you let go of the stick, the horse will weave through without issues. You might get clotheslined though.

76

u/gavinderulo124K Mar 31 '25

Exactly. If people run into things on their horse, it's because they are actively steering into them. I never had that issue, as I let the horse dodge on its own.

31

u/VoopityScoop Mar 31 '25

The issue is that the horse's own dodging doesn't turn off when you're actively steering. That way, you'll try and make one maneuver, but the horse will go a different direction instead, often directly into the thing you were trying to steer around.

4

u/EffectiveShopDweller Apr 01 '25

Like… real horses.

3

u/lemonade_eyescream Final Fantasy XXVII Apr 01 '25

I feel like in the case of conflict the horse should go the horse's way, but it should turn its head to side-eye the player lol

2

u/Numerous_Photograph9 Mar 31 '25

A horse will not generally speed head first into their own death. There are many funny videos of RDR2 horses doing just that, so steering into them is also not realistic.

Otherwise, I'd say the horses do behave pretty realistically in the game, and outside of maybe getting into a wonky camera angle, I never really had a problem running into stuff like that.

2

u/Hyperious17 Apr 02 '25

the amount of times I've just straight up ran into large rocks so baffling tbh

1

u/ShirtPanties Apr 01 '25

I agree that it’s almost always avoidable but a couple times I had my horse running full speed with my finger off the stick, and the horse would just run full speed into a rock or a tree, usually a rock that would trip it and send me flying, once sending me right off a cliff

15

u/ChakaZG Mar 31 '25 edited Jul 28 '25

rob history tart spoon vase lunchroom intelligent cake judicious fuel

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

2

u/Blackrain1299 Apr 04 '25

Mu horse tends to jump over things at a weird angle if i happen to be running alongside something. It almost always ends with her landing on the fence she tried to jump and knocking us down.

4

u/CaneDogXXXX Mar 31 '25

Or climb on buildings and stalls

8

u/krob58 Mar 31 '25

They consulted with Roach here for maximum authenticity

1

u/TheWallaceWithin Mar 31 '25

I've always just let go of the left stick and the horse navigates through the trees on its own.

1

u/ElegantEchoes Mar 31 '25

Genuinely difficult to hit trees from my experience, even when I try to steer into them haha. But I've seen it happen to a lot of people.

1

u/pmercier Mar 31 '25

Bro, horses have a blind spot between the eyes, if your horse isn’t accidentally running into something right in front of it, you ain’t horsing right.

1

u/GreenPhoen1x Apr 01 '25

That's 100% a skill problem. Even the fastest and most twitchy RDR2 horses ride through forests fine when you know how to play.

1

u/Logical-Professor325 Apr 01 '25

The horse dodges stuff on its own but people try and steer it making it crash

1

u/babagroovy Apr 01 '25

Underrated lmfao