r/playstation Mar 31 '25

Discussion Which game has the better horses?

Post image
7.2k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

1.5k

u/Zxar99 Mar 31 '25

AC’s horse looks better, but RDR2 horses feel and act more like real horses. Giving it to RDR2

456

u/ElegantEchoes Mar 31 '25

R* had a whole department working on the horses for years. It took lots of work and time to get right. They really wanted them to feel like an animal with its own inertial physics and wanted to portray some of the different ways horses can behave. The different techniques you'd learn when bonding with the horse and the whole confidence system was quite cool.

254

u/Bob69748742 Mar 31 '25

Like how much horses love to run into trees at high speeds

111

u/stuffeh Mar 31 '25

Usually, if you let go of the stick, the horse will weave through without issues. You might get clotheslined though.

74

u/gavinderulo124K Mar 31 '25

Exactly. If people run into things on their horse, it's because they are actively steering into them. I never had that issue, as I let the horse dodge on its own.

29

u/VoopityScoop Mar 31 '25

The issue is that the horse's own dodging doesn't turn off when you're actively steering. That way, you'll try and make one maneuver, but the horse will go a different direction instead, often directly into the thing you were trying to steer around.

4

u/EffectiveShopDweller Apr 01 '25

Like… real horses.

3

u/lemonade_eyescream Final Fantasy XXVII Apr 01 '25

I feel like in the case of conflict the horse should go the horse's way, but it should turn its head to side-eye the player lol

2

u/Numerous_Photograph9 Mar 31 '25

A horse will not generally speed head first into their own death. There are many funny videos of RDR2 horses doing just that, so steering into them is also not realistic.

Otherwise, I'd say the horses do behave pretty realistically in the game, and outside of maybe getting into a wonky camera angle, I never really had a problem running into stuff like that.

2

u/Hyperious17 Apr 02 '25

the amount of times I've just straight up ran into large rocks so baffling tbh

1

u/ShirtPanties Apr 01 '25

I agree that it’s almost always avoidable but a couple times I had my horse running full speed with my finger off the stick, and the horse would just run full speed into a rock or a tree, usually a rock that would trip it and send me flying, once sending me right off a cliff