r/politics Foreign Dec 13 '17

Black voters just saved America from Roy Moore

https://thinkprogress.org/back-vote-alabama-jones-8da18c1d8d7a/
49.6k Upvotes

6.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

462

u/MimonFishbaum Dec 13 '17

Sure, but 9 years ago we elected the first black president and look where we are now. It's a very nice win, but complacency put us in the position we are in now.

135

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '17

100%

64

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '17

[deleted]

13

u/leftshoe18 Minnesota Dec 13 '17

And 100% reason to remember the name

6

u/spirited1 Dec 13 '17

Russia was just enough to put the election in Trump's favour. It was a needlessly close race any way you look at it though.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '17

mhmm the number might be lower than 95 now that you mention it lol

0

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '17

Where do we put the percentage for "running a terrible candidate"

38

u/MediMike92 New York Dec 13 '17

Yes, but we are also given a constant stream of things to be mad about every single day. The news just keeps coming at a pace that we've never seen before. That might be enough to keep people from becoming complacent, but only time will tell.

8

u/AerieC Minnesota Dec 13 '17

Yes, but we are also given a constant stream of things to be mad about every single day

Yeah, which is exactly what's been happening on the right for decades. Fox news, Breitbart, Infowars, it's all a constant stream of bullshit that induces rage in the right-wing.

They're being told every day, "better get out and vote or these democrats will kill babies!", "get out and vote or these democrats will let terrorists in to the country!", "get out and vote or these democrats will let illegals in to the country to steal your jobs!", "get out and vote or these democrats will steal your hard earned money and give it to undeserving welfare queens who will spend it on booze and drugs!"

The right is fueled by outrage, and that's why they actually get out and vote. It doesn't matter that their outrage is manufactured, it's effective.

5

u/brova Massachusetts Dec 13 '17

I'm 27, and up until the 2016 election I had previously only voted in the Presidential elections of 2008 and 2012. No more. I will now vote in every single election at every single level of government for the rest of my life. It's a somewhat meaningless gesture, living in Boston, but it's something I plan on making a life long habit of. I'd wager I'm not alone.

2

u/LadyMichelle00 Dec 13 '17

Good for you and so glad to hear!

2

u/halfdeadmoon Dec 13 '17

I would expect more desensitization and despair in the long term

3

u/MimonFishbaum Dec 13 '17

It's been that way for more than 10yrs now.

2

u/ryanmlt12 Dec 13 '17

Your us vs. them mentality is disturbing. We are all in this together.

6

u/lingh0e Dec 13 '17

Thank you Grace, but I think you're wrong. It's precisely the us vs them mentally that got the pivotal voters out this time. Think about the fact that Roy Moore was flat-out labeled as a pedophile and how the democrats fucking hammered that label hard. It was a page straight from the GOP playbook. The guy was very unqualified to hold the position he was campaigning for for a litany of reasons, but the pedophile angle was the dominant one. We did an amazing job of making his name synonymous with creeping for underage tail. If this is the way things are going to be in order for us to reclaim a solid hold on our government, so be it.

1

u/ryanmlt12 Dec 13 '17 edited Dec 13 '17

You did it again, us (Dems). Its sad that everyone assumes you're liberal on Reddit.

15

u/Ultraballer Dec 13 '17

Who knew the first woman candidate would be so much more controversial than the first black one

21

u/delorean225 Dec 13 '17

I mean, black men got the vote before women did...

3

u/sometimeserin Dec 13 '17 edited Dec 13 '17

constitutionally yes but in practice not really

2

u/LadyMichelle00 Dec 13 '17

Can you clarify please?

4

u/Magyman Dec 13 '17

I'd assume stuff like literacy tests.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '17

Literacy tests, black votes didn’t count as full votes, harassment at voting centers, etc. IIRC, one of the main reasons the KKK gained traction was because of blacks receiving rights. The law (begrudgingly, it was more of a political power move) stated that black men could vote legally, but much of society saw it as unacceptable that lesser humans be treated equally.

0

u/CptnLarsMcGillicutty Dec 13 '17

the differences between black people and white people are much smaller than the differences between men and women.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '17

Physiologically? Yeah. Socially and culturally? Two different planets.

When it comes down to it, humans really aren’t that different. Culture and social geography really sets people apart.

2

u/badkarmabum Dec 13 '17

I disagree. I have far more in common with black men than white women. Mainstream feminism has historically silenced black women while they were often leaders in black movements. The race wage gap is far larger than the gender gap. And black men have far more incentive to greatly alter the status quo.

1

u/Ultraballer Dec 13 '17

You have to understand that there is 0 evidence that will support this claim right? We are incapable of testing nature vs buried arguments, and so it’s silly to make such bold claims with no evidence

13

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '17 edited Jan 18 '18

[deleted]

4

u/Thallis Dec 13 '17

Her voting record was one of the most liberal in Congress. She was left of Obama on most issues.

2

u/LadyMichelle00 Dec 13 '17

Exactly. How Hillary rage is so deep is beyond me.

3

u/Ultraballer Dec 13 '17

Obama is probably the most beautiful speaking president I have been alive to see. He’s clear, concise, always looks authoritative and in control of the situation. He was presidential.

8

u/HorizonMan Dec 13 '17

That may be partially true, but there are a lot of people on both sides who really didn't like Hillary and that's also part of why they didn't turn out. They didn't think Trump could possibly win and didn't want to vote for Hillary. Though her being a woman was a sadly a factor for some, for those who could have made the difference, it was about her being her.

2

u/LadyMichelle00 Dec 13 '17

But what has ever actually panned out as some specific examples of why Hillary is so hated?

1

u/Ultraballer Dec 13 '17

As someone who voted for her, she has some pretty big flaws. The biggest one I hear, she has huge lobbying ties. She takes in millions a year, and has for decades along with her husband from various corporations across America. For example her annual income is somewhere around 30 mill, where as Bernie is sitting at just under 500k, mostly because she takes corporate money. She is probably going to start more wars in the Middle East, she is willing to put more troops on the ground, and try to increase military presence. Just a couple, and nothing like what trumps pulling off, but generally a sub par candidate

0

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '17

Can’t speak for everyone, but Hillary and Bill Clinton both have a pretty bad reputation with the black community due to previous policies and statements. The votes cast her way weren’t so much because she was a good candidate, but a lesser, known evil.

2

u/DatPiff916 Dec 13 '17

Who knew

Putin knew.

2

u/Dear_Occupant Tennessee Dec 13 '17

Pretty much anyone familiar with the suffrage movement. Women's rights have always come in second place to those of men, regardless of their color.

-2

u/tyler-86 Dec 13 '17

Well, women and men have some fundamental differences. Race is cosmetic, aside from a few health risks and the way society treats you.

Although I did think we'd have a Jewish president before we had a black one.

1

u/LadyMichelle00 Dec 13 '17

Fundamental differences? Like what? (Besides obvious physical differences)

2

u/tyler-86 Dec 13 '17

I'd rather not dive too deep down this rabbit hole but there are more physiological differences between a man and a woman than between two men of different races. That's all. It doesn't make a woman any less capable or qualified, but it probably (stupidly) makes some people more reticent to vote for a woman than a black man.

1

u/LadyMichelle00 Dec 15 '17

Fair enough. Thanks for the explanation. Appreciate it.

1

u/Ultraballer Dec 13 '17

Oh no you don’t want to go down that rabbit hole. Every single person will spew different nonsense, as if they have PhD’s in behavioural psychology, only to decide we have 0 actual ability to isolate gender as a variable, no nature vs nurture argument over Reddit is going to prove useful

5

u/tkdyo Dec 13 '17

I would argue the party leaders had a lot more to do with where we are than the voters themselves. It's hard to get masses of people to go out and vote when theres no message behind it other than "at least we aren't Republicans". Hopefully this year has been a wake up call for both the base AND the establishment.

1

u/MimonFishbaum Dec 13 '17

In other words, complacency.

1

u/tkdyo Dec 13 '17

Eh, I tend to think actively trying to keep the same leaders in power is a bit different from complacency. Plus the original post sounded like you were only blaming the voters and giving the establishment a pass. If that wasn't you're intent, my bad.

1

u/publicram Dec 13 '17

That was because black voter came out and voted too..

1

u/MimonFishbaum Dec 13 '17

Weird how that works.

1

u/publicram Dec 13 '17

Sure but did they just vote for him because he was black... So much of or voting is done simply because he's a democrat because he's a republican. Voting is difficult on one side we have a idiot running for office on the other side we have a crook... I chose the lesser of two evils and voted third party.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '17

No lie, I voted for Obama because he was black. Growing up, it’s hard not to idolize drug dealers or athletes or rappers. They’re a vast majority of the successful blacks you see. Of course, there’s doctors, lawyers, and other black professionals, but they often distance themselves from most of the community where drug dealers, athletes, and rappers usually fully embrace it. They’re more relatable.

It was refreshing to see someone own who he was as a black man and be president. Working in schools in the inner city at the time, it’s refreshing to see kids say they want to be president instead of thinking they have to put their physical well-being on the line as an athlete as a way to make it out of the ghetto.

I regret nothing.

1

u/publicram Dec 13 '17

That's great... But I am a minority, I lived a block away from the trap as a kid. My cousin used to make me fight the other kids for money in front of my gmas house. I was about 8 . I don't want to hear this bs. To me vote for the best person that will make America better, whatever vision that you see vote for the person that does that. Forget skin color.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '17 edited Dec 13 '17

And if you saw McCain or Clinton as a better candidate, that’s great. Obama was the best president we’ve had in my lifetime. And saying someone would’ve been better is subjective and theoretical. Still regret nothing.

Also, America did get “better” under Obama. Remember the recession Bush put us in? Or the hard push against LGBT rights? Maybe the DEA shutting down medical marijuana dispensaries will jog your memory. America was straight trash when Obama was elected. Not going to sit here like Obama is some god, but to say he was a bad president may be a personal bias.

1

u/publicram Dec 13 '17

Im not arguing that Obama was better than Bush blah blah blah trump suck blah blah. Im saying vote for the person that you think is right for the ideas you pursue, not because of skin color.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '17

My views aligned with his, just can’t deny that him being black played a decent part in my pick. It also played a decent part in our foreign interactions and people don’t acknowledge that. We’re viewed as xenophobic, gun toting, pride filled people to a lot of countries. We gained respect from a lot of countries just from electing Obama. Can’t remember what country, but they said America wasn’t even ready for a black president. It showed an advancement as a country. We took like 8 steps back with Trump, but...yeah.

trump sucks

Definitely would cop you a beer though lol

0

u/MimonFishbaum Dec 13 '17

You could look at it that way or look at it like nominating a candidate who could mobilize a base.

1

u/publicram Dec 13 '17

I just don't see where we went wrong as Americans.. was America always like this, I grew up in a small Texas town and we had pride in what we did. I understand people have different values and see things differently but I think to myself how did if Moore molested children.( I haven't done the research to make an opinion) how did he become so powerful, how was he not stopped prior to this. Regardless of views how does this happen. What has happened to my America

1

u/Wdc331 Dec 13 '17

BINGO. We cannot get complacent. We cannot let people forget what a giant shit stain on our country the GOP has become. I never in a million years thought I and the rest of the developed world would be paying such rapt attention to a special senate election in Alabama. We need to keep this momentum going.

1

u/MagnesiumStearate Dec 13 '17

It was definitely complacency on the parts of the liberal that Trump won. However on the flip side, Trump also won because he was able to rally certain disenfranchised "conservative" groups to go out and vote for him, when most of them have not voted in decades.

The truth is not one side can be complacent. Voting to keep a pedophile/an abortion supporter out of office is still a demonstration of democracy and it is on everyone of us to take our parts to share the narrative we want to see.

1

u/telmnstr Dec 13 '17

The black president didn't address the issues of the declining middle class.

1

u/oopsiedaisymeohmy Dec 13 '17

the line of progress ain't straight, friend!

1

u/galwegian Dec 13 '17

i blame the aging boomers. shaking their walking sticks at Fox News. They are still causing trouble the old fuckers. good news? they will all be gone soon.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '17

*half black President.

0

u/DwarfTheMike Dec 13 '17

Yeah but he also didn’t stop the wars overseas and even expanded them. Sure, he was black, but he wasn’t much different. He catered to the bankers and wall street. He was deported in chief. He created a lot of what we are dealing with by catering to Wall Street and their business interests.

I’m not at all a trump supporter, I just don’t like blind faith in Obama. I did vote for him, but I was very disappointed in him, and we should all be for him breaking his promises. We can’t forget that. Th democratic part isn’t going to make things better. We need a much greater shakeup.

1

u/MimonFishbaum Dec 13 '17

I didn't apply any blind faith here. Just the complacency in mobilizing certain demographics of the Democratic party. They got lazy and focused too much on a base that will never vote for them.

0

u/DwarfTheMike Dec 13 '17

Yeah I wasn’t necessarily accusing you of that. That last part was more to show where I was coming from.

They did they lazy. The party got greedy with Wall Street money, and the voters stopped paying attention to what was important. Obama was great at making people feel good.

0

u/TreeRol American Expat Dec 13 '17

Theoretically, 2000 would have been a reminder to never sit out another election. Then 2010. Then 2016.

Seems we need to learn this lesson again every 5 to 10 years. 2022 is going to be ugly.

0

u/Tazer79 Dec 13 '17

Smug, dishonest politics put us where we are now with Trump.

0

u/MimonFishbaum Dec 13 '17

Six and one...