r/vexillology • u/Death_and_Gravity1 • 1d ago
Redesigns My favorites of the Massachusetts flag redesign finalists
Here are the finalists: https://www.mass.gov/doc/seal-flag-motto-submissions-2nd-round-commissioner-selections/download
58
u/skepticCanary 1d ago
- Because fish.
3
2
1
u/KSPReptile 16h ago
I don't like the colors but the design is cool.
2
u/skepticCanary 16h ago
Agree with the colours. It doesn’t need the two shades of blue, one would look better.
1
u/KSPReptile 16h ago
I was thinking white and blue like some of the others are using, only blue would be pretty boring.
And use less muted colors. For some reason a lot of these latest redesigns use these muted and dark shades and it just makes the flags look so drab and I suspect is one of the reasons why a lot of people think they look too corporate and samey.
13
u/Death_and_Gravity1 1d ago
You can see all of the 1000+ submissions here: https://www.mass.gov/doc/massachusetts-seal-flag-motto-submissions/download
1
u/TheManFromFairwinds Argentina 23h ago
Really dug a lot of the ones with a cranberry background, shame only a couple seem to have made the cut. Also I feel like a lighthouse is a great symbol for the state but none hit the spot quite right for me.
1
13
u/cnp_nick 1d ago edited 1d ago
Maybe they should move the Minuteman so he’s not ominously facing the Native American but otherwise I quite like the last one. It’s the only one that looks it could be a state flag. Most of the others have that corporate logo feel to them.
Edit: Slide #171 has Oklahoma vibes that I quite like.
11
u/Carmen_Caramel 1d ago edited 1d ago
15
7
u/Pennonymous_bis 1d ago edited 1d ago
12
u/Pennonymous_bis 1d ago
3
u/Pennonymous_bis 1d ago
6
u/SeaToShy 1d ago
The combination of Nova Scotia and Massachusetts would be terrifying. 50% incredibly nice, 50% trash talking you relentlessly. The Kelly Olynyk of subnational entities.
6
6
u/Sirpunchdirt 1d ago
This is going better than other redesigns. Some genuinely cool flags in this.
Now I'm just jealous sitting here the next state over. Please Ned Lamont, my lord, give unto us a flag redesign.
5
u/Candid_Interview_268 Austria 1d ago
2
u/DryProgress4393 1d ago edited 1d ago
5 looks good. I like the connection with the city of Boston colours.
2
u/Swimming_Rope_9706 22h ago
I like the one with the Indian warrior and the frontiersman. The others feel too corporate or not Massachusettsy enough.
2
2
1
1
u/Ca1rill 23h ago edited 22h ago
For number 6, they should switch the white guy and the Indigenous guy so it doesn't look like the white guy is pointing his rifle at the Indigenous guy. The whole point of the redesign was because of the optics of the sword looking like it was taking a swipe at the Native American. This proposal recreates the whole scenario that inspired the redesign in the first place.
1
1
u/Tsunamix0147 New England 19h ago
1, 3, & 5 take the cake. These redesigns have shown themselves time and time again in different ways, and each time, they work perfectly. I hope any of those get selected, especially 5.
1
u/KSPReptile 16h ago
I think the tree shape looks a bit goofy so I think I prefer some of the other designs, from these the last one is the best. But I looked at the link and also liked the very first flag with the lighthouse and the one with the feathers in a circle.
1
u/SellItCheap 10h ago
!wave
1
u/FlagWaverBotReborn 10h ago
1
1
1
u/Train115 3h ago
That last one is pretty good, the others are kinda generic but better than the "top three flags" which are incredibly generic.
1
1
1
0
u/LifeOrchid4367 1d ago
I don’t like it when flags have excessive amounts of white on them. White is a passive color that evokes incompetence and weakness.
0
u/Immediate_Guest_2790 1d ago
The pine tree and the colour buff are regional symbols, not just Mess colours.
0
0
0
0
-3
u/TJ-Detweiler- 1d ago
These are all terrible except for maybe the last one. Why are they changing the flag?
-7
u/LavalSnack 1d ago
The last wouldn't work you'd have too many people whining about the gun pointing at the Indian
We also shouldn't have Indians on the flag, they wrfe conquered them and whatever remains is sub 2% of the whole so no real need to represent them.
-15
u/RogueStatesman 1d ago
Yeesh. The original beats any of these.
6
u/ted5298 Germany 1d ago
The original beats NONE of these besides maybe #2. Please stop being a blind reactionary.
-4
u/RogueStatesman 1d ago
It's not reactionary to dislike ugly stuff.
1
3
u/Death_and_Gravity1 1d ago
The original is just a seel on a blank canvas. We need less of those in the world
72
u/___Aquarius___ 1d ago
Dunkin’ Dino will live on in our hearts