r/whowouldwin • u/Historical_Ostrich • Aug 02 '25

Battle An unarmed Captain America (MCU) replaces Robb Stark at the Red Wedding - can he fight his way out?

Cap doesn't have his shield or suit, and he doesn't know that the betrayal is coming. The Freys are not aware of his upgraded abilities.

Can Cap fight his way out? Bonus points if he can keep Catelyn and Robb's wife safe. Double bonus points if he can kill Walder Frey and Roose Bolton.

670 Upvotes

94% Upvoted

300 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/ErosDarlingAlt Aug 02 '25

I think best case scenario he escapes alone, or maybe with Catelyn. Talisa is the first to die, so I doubt he can save her without premonition.

I also doubt he could murder Walder and Roose without dying himself.

2

u/Chen932000 Aug 02 '25

Cap is pretty observant. He may notice things being odd before Catelyn which buys him a bit more time. Saying Talisa is only really doable if he can throw something lethal at the guy going to murder her. I agree she probably dies. Walker and Roose can both be killed again just by having things thrown at them if he wants to. Saving Catelyn may be doable if he immediately flees with her (though I dont recall if there were any man sized windows in the main room.

1

u/ErosDarlingAlt Aug 02 '25

This would be the decider, you're right. If he isn't surprised, it all goes way differently.