r/whowouldwin • u/xWolfpaladin • Aug 09 '18
Special Clash of Titans - Round 2
The Clash of Titans
Tier Setter
Any participant can submit either:
3 entrant that can achieve a Unlikely Victory - Likely Victory against bloodlusted Iron Fist (each entrant should be able to 1v1 iron fist)
OR
1 entrant that can achieve a Unlikely Victory - Likely Victory against bloodlusted Luke Cage
Both of these combatants will be using Tournament Specific RTs that will be provided, the goal being to use a high-end version of these characters that leave as little interpretation to entrants as possible.
Here are the Tournament specific RTs
Specifics
Each participant can submit a team of 3 Iron Fist Tier Characters AND/OR 1 Luke Cage Tier Character. You can choose to submit only 1 of these options, so submitting only 1 Luke Cage, or submit characters fitting both descriptions. How this works is that you private message a judge before the round starts telling them whether you want to use your 3 Iron Fists or your 1 Luke Cage in the upcoming round, and then that will be kept secret until the round goes up. If you do not message a judge before the round goes up, then it will be decided for you by coin flip.
Battle rules
Speed will be equalized to a base of 257 meters per second (mach .75). Reactions are equalized to 5 milliseconds. However, speed boosts by character abilities are allowed. Projectiles are relative in speed to the character.
Arena
Its the most densely populated city in North America, it's where Frank Sinatra wants to go, you know it as the Big apple. It's New York City. Characters start 514 meters apart. Your characters know that they have to defeat their opponent to leave the city. The only way your characters can defeat there opponents is by killing or incapacitating them - BFR is not an option.
- The fights start in the exact center of NYC with opposing teams starting 500 meters away from each other, and characters on the same team will start 10 meters away from their teammates.
For the purpose of this tournament, assume there are no other people in NYC.
Debate Rules
If either you or your opponent is using a Luke cage tier Character, then you both are limited to 2 comments of 10k characters for each response, and have 3 main responses. If both participants are using the 3 Iron fist tier character then you are both limited to 3 comments of 10k characters, and have 3 main responses.
The exact format will be Intro/First Response/Second Response/Third Response/Conclusion.
Your intro should give us a good idea of the power level of your characters, which ones you're using, and who they are.
Your conclusion should sum up arguments you've already brought forth.
A conclusion may be submitted any time after both third responses have been done.
Victory Conditions
Winning a match will be determined by a council of judges including myself, u/epizestro, and u/he-man69.
Judges won't judge on their preconceived notions of how strong the characters are, but rather on how well you argue them to win
How long is this round?
Round 2 will last 5 days, from August 9th to August 14th, 12pm est.
However, if you are unable to submit a response in time for the deadline, due to real life concerns or similar, please request an extension from a judge.
OOT calling during the Tournament Proper
As this is a debate tournament, it would be a bit silly to not be allowed to debate things. As such your debate skills will be put to the test if or when your Opponent calls your characters OOT during the Rounds. Simply debate better than your opponent and your characters will stay in the tournament.
OOT arguments in the tournament proper will be handled as a separate decision from the main judgements. How this works is that, should you argue OOT, whether you were successful will be decided by a judge vote, and then the judgements will proceed taking the result of the vote into account.
Miscellaneous Rules.
There will be an unbreakable sphere around the arena, and as such no one can enter or leave. You cannot teleport outside the dome (Characters like Nightcrawler will be allowed to teleport, but cannot actually exit the dome). There is no possible way for a character to enter or leave.
The fights start in the exact center of NYC with opposing teams starting 500 meters away from each other, and characters on the same team will start 10 meters away from their teammates.
All weapons begin holstered, however all draw feats scale to movement speed.
The battles will start at high noon unless stipulated otherwise
For something to count as incapacitatation it would need to last for 3 minutes.
Characters are in-character for the actual tournament
Characters in a 3v1 are lined up as they are submitted. 1v1s will be randomized.
You must give your opponent a chance to get two responses in. You cannot purposefully delay a response to deprive your opponent of one.
All rules are subject to judge discretion.
Round 2
Updated Bracket
Randomized 1v1 Order
If your team entirely consists of Iron Fist tiers, and the enemy does as well, you will be split into 3 1v1s.
If either have a Luke Cage tier, or two Luke tiers, it will be a 1v3 or 1v1.
1v2
2v3
3v1
Round 1 Matchups
- Coconut-Crab vs [removed]
3 v 1
- Kjell vs HighSlayerRalton
3 v 1
- Mikhailnikolaievitch vs Kirbin
3 v 1
- TheMightyBox72 vs ImadeThis
3 v 1
- GuyOfEvil vs Fj668
3 v 1
- BlackBloodedLord vs British_Tea_Company
3 v 1
- Ame-No-Nobuko vs EmbraceAllDeath
3 v 1
1
u/GuyOfEvil Aug 10 '18
Third Response
Shooting small targets from a short distance directly correlates to somebody's ability to shoot larger targets from a long distance. Phantom Rider's insane accuracy at close range should be more than enough to shoot a man in the process of dodging an attack.
This scaling is actually extremely questionable. Firstly this clearly isn't a heat resistance feat for Hyoh considering he was already dead before the lava, and its not even provably a heat resistance feat for Kaioh, considering we see his body get covered in lava and then that's the last we see of him.
Even if you assume this is a heat resistance feat, there's no way to scale these people's heat resistance to Kenshiro just because they fought.
I'd agree that Kenshiro is stronger than Spider-Man considering he can do more than Spider-Man's high ends, but how much Spider-Man struggles doesn't really matter. The Jackal knows Peter down to the atom, and calibrates the chains massively above his strength output. So Kaine is stronger than Peter's highest possible end.
I have no idea where this comes from. He thinks "Damn." and then is blown off his feet. There's literally a period.
Wall crawling can be overpowered. I won't scale to it since there's no evidence he uses it, but him not specifically mentioning using it isn't evidence he didn't.
Where's your evidence that Kaine isn't weakened from this? Kaine couldn't have possibly been at his peak if he's been fighting against an entire team of people.
It was a short fight in which he was only hit three times, and he went into Roxxon that night, there's no reason for him to be very weakened.
Besides that, what do you suppose would weaken him more, a fight where he took three hits and ran away that happened several hours ago, or a long drawn out fight where he fought Spider-Ock, several mutant spiders, and Carrion, at the end of which he could barely stand, because that was what he was coming off of when he preformed the chains feat.
He has no anti-feats of failing to knock over somebody stronger than Scarlet Spider, this isn't PIS, its just a feat.
Except they aren't smaller. These are bigger than a decent amount of the tornadoes he's been inside, including the one he pushed back Thing in. And heck, knocking down Scarlet Spider is better than most of the feats of tornados he's in. He can generate the same amount of wind weather he's in or out of the tornado, and its the same wind being generated. There's literally no reason to believe one would be weaker than the other.
Damage output wise sure, but damage doesn't really matter against wind. Texas Twister has displaced more with his wind than Kenshiro has with his aura, so if Kenshiro tried to displace Texas Twister's wind with his aura, he would very likely lose.
Based on my opponent's arguments, Kenshiro will block noticible ranged attacks with aura. If that's the case, it stands to reason he would attempt to block Phantom Rider's shots with aura, which would result in him dying.
I doubt Firebird will open up with her absolute strongest attack against Kenshiro.
Both of these are true, sure, but if she realizes her normal attacks aren't doing anything she'll likely go for a stronger attack.
If a normal attack had no effect, she'd probably think he'd be able to at least survive a stronger attack.
There is no scan of him using it at more than a few feet's distance. He starts basically in range of my team, and as he approaches to attack he'll only become an easier target.
The claim that he uses whatever technique gives him the greatest chance of victory and then examples of him using extraordinary attacks when simple ones would do seem... at odds to say the least. If he were to use the most effective technique in every fight he would stay at range constantly, but he fights in melee all the time.
There is no reason to believe he will fight in a manner he has literally never fought in before against completely unknown opponents.
It will take him at best two full seconds to close the distance, which is only if he doesn't struggle against the winds at all, and doesn't stop to block anything with aura. In those two seconds he will become easier and easier to hit, and my team will have the opportunity to put out several attacks that will severely injure Kenshiro.
He has literally never used this technique before. There isn't even evidence that he knows this technique considering he's never seen it. That's Raoh in the scan not him.
Comparing aim skill to martial arts skill is pretty difficult, but I don't see how Kenshiro's skill will allow him to dodge large amounts of bullets.
This invisibility is a lot different than fighting an invisible opponent with a gun from range. And even then he just barely beats this.
It will allow Phanton Rider to attack from multiple angles from range. Phantom Rider could, for instance, shoot Kenshiro then have his hand appear in the direction Kenshiro is dodging.
He's fought with them once and is usually a villain, I doubt he'll care much.
He's accurate enough to get headshots, and will probably be going for one