r/whowouldwin • u/selfproclaimed • Oct 24 '18
Special Character Rumble Nominations 10/23/2018
What is this?
If you've been a regular at /r/characterrant you might know what this is. Moving forward we're going to have a stickied WWW post of a standard one on one matchup. There will be a nominations post where users like yourself can submit up to three matchups with details on the specifics of the rounds.
For examples of what CharacterRumble was on in /r/characterrant, feel free to look here, here, and here.
What we're looking for are submissions that are
Detailed and present interesting scenarios. Just putting in Batman vs. Captain America is boring, but giving them a unique challenge is going to catch our notice.
Contain easily researchable information for both characters (e.e. respect threads).
Are competitive and inspire debate
Thoughtfully constructed (you get noticed more easily if you include things like location, conditions, etc.)
Want some examples of great submissions? Look here, here, and here. You don't have to format your matches in tables, but it won't hurt.
In this nominations thread, feel free to comment on submissions that you think could foster good discussion or critique on how they could be improved.
After this, we'll go over the submissions and pick two of them to be stickied in the next weekly CharacterRumble.
2
u/PreroastedTaco Oct 24 '18 edited Oct 24 '18
Batman (DC - Post Crises) vs Nightwing (DC - Post Crises)
Respect PC Batman
Respect PC Nightwing
General conditions:
They start 12m from each other.
Combat begins immediately for both parties.
Battlefield removal counts as a loss. If someone is thrown from the skyscraper in Round 2 they need to make their way back up in under 10 seconds. Running away for over 200m counts as a loss. This applies to Round 2 but doesn't count for the fall/climb.