r/whowouldwin 2d ago

Challenge Batman takes on a Dark Souls lifting strength gauntlet

1 Upvotes

Batman (comics, post-Flashpoint) has to overcome a gauntlet of Dark Souls characters in a lifting contest. Specifically a conventional deadlift, one rep max. Whoever lifts more weight wins the round.

Assume all characters are in their prime and that fatigue, soreness, etc. don’t affect Batman as he progresses.

  1. Siegmeyer of Catarina

  2. Solaire of Astora

  3. Sister Friede

  4. Sir Alonne

  5. Artorias the Abysswalker

  6. Dragonslayer Ornstein

  7. Raime, the Fume Knight

  8. The Nameless King

  9. Slave Knight Gael

  10. Gwyn, Lord of Sunlight


r/whowouldwin 2d ago

Battle Can the TOS Enterprise and its crew conquer Westeros and place Kirk on the Iron Throne, without killing anyone?

29 Upvotes

Some omnipotent space god or other, on a lark, has tasked the crew of the Enterprise to subjugate The Seven Kingdoms lest it destroy the Federation.

Victory is achieved when the leaders of the Great Houses swear an oath of vassalhood to James T Kirk while he sits upon the Iron Throne.

Can the Enterprise make that happen while not killing anyone?


r/whowouldwin 2d ago

Battle Injustice Superman vs Hit (DBS)

2 Upvotes

The fight takes place on flat ground, and both are at a distance of 100m from each other. Both are bloodluster. Who wins?


r/whowouldwin 2d ago

Battle "free for all" | all pokemon vs all heros and villains | (TerminalMontage Clips vs ArtSpear Entertainment)

2 Upvotes

fight potential: after oscar was done with his villain or superhero brawl he get a idea. a bigger idea. seeing TerminalMontage pokemon battle royale he makes all the hero's/villain all fight the pokemon in the arena in a total war. in the climax pokemon like Magcargo or Yveltal basically nukes the world. leaving the pokemon and heros and villains that can fly in space left. and then we can have the last ones left like doctor manhattan vs Arceus 

winner (my opinion): pokemon win do to all the world ending bullshit. unless if manhattan oneshot everyone. what do you think?


r/whowouldwin 2d ago

Battle the UNSC of halo (before the covenant war) vs the Earth Alliance of Babylon 5 (before the minbari war)

3 Upvotes

Total war.

wihtout Alies.

no rules.


r/whowouldwin 2d ago

Battle Wolverine vs Leonidas vs Deathstroke vs Rex vs Samurai Jack vs Huu vs Ezio

1 Upvotes

Location: First hunger games arena

Prep Time: 24 hours

Versions: Wolverine (2013, no regeneration) Leonidas (300, with 30 Spartans) Deathstroke (Arrowverse) Commander Rex (Star Wars, Phase Two Clone Wars era) Samurai Jack (Season 1) Huu (Avatar the Last Airbender) Ezio (Assassin's Creed Revelations)

Rules: All Gear is taken and placed in the Cornucopia in the center of the arena. The fight will be hunger games style with each contestant starting on a pad that is about 50 yards from the Cornucopia. Leonidas doesn't count as out until he and all of the Spartans are out.

Who survives? Who dies first?


r/whowouldwin 2d ago

Battle Mr. Incredible (The Incredibles 1-2 | All Statements + Feats) Vs Red Hulk (MCU | All Statements + Feats)

3 Upvotes

my opinion so far:

Lifting Strength: Mr. Incredible

Striking Strength: Red Hulk

Speed: Red Hulk

Agility: Red Hulk

Blunt Durability: Mr. Incredible (debatable)

Piercing Durability: Red Hulk

Endurance: Red Hulk

IQ: Mr. Incredible

Battle IQ: Mr. Incredible

Combat: Mr. Incredible

Skills: Mr. Incredible

C/R Speed: Mr. Incredible

Power: Red Hulk

Hax: Red Hulk

Stamina: Red Hulk

AP: Red Hulk

DC: Red Hulk

Abilities: Red Hulk

Offense: >=

Defense: Mr. Incredible

Experience: Mr. Incredible

Battle Experience: Mr. Incredible

Feats: Mr. Incredible (>=)

Winner?: Red Hulk (Mid-High Diff)


r/whowouldwin 2d ago

Battle Who is the strongest character in my little cousin (6 years old) can beat based off his accomplishments?

34 Upvotes

Here they are

  1. He is a big hockey player (let’s say 6 foot four and 250 pounds)

2.He can run faster than a tsunami (in the deep ocean, they can go around 500 mph)

  1. He is I quote “way stronger than daddy” (around five times stronger than the average male)

  2. He can fly but not around his family or friends because he doesn’t want to embarrass anyone

  3. If he punches you, you will fly across the entire city (extremely strong punch force)


r/whowouldwin 2d ago

Battle Lucifer (DC) Vs Lucifer (World of Darkness), Who would win?

2 Upvotes

R1: battle takes place in DC, they fight on sight. No prep time is involved.

R2: battle takes place in world of darkness, again they fight on sight. No prep time involved.

R3: Battle Takes place in a neutral infinite arena, both get 30 minutes prep time. They have knowledge of each other and their feats. They don't have the experience or knowledge from the previous rounds.


r/whowouldwin 2d ago

Battle Guy who can teleport with laser pointer vs. Guy who can switch places with opponent

7 Upvotes

Teleporter guy has a green laser pointer. When he turns on the laser, he will teleport to the location when and where the beam stops (gets scattered or absorbed). His clothes and the laser pointer teleport with him.

Switch places guy has a watch with a button on it. When he presses the button his body position and velocity switch with laser pointer guy. His clothes+watch also teleport with him of course.

Both abilities have a 5 s cooldown. Both fighters have 5+ years of training with their respective weapons but no prep for this particular fight. Fight takes place in a random street in NYC at night. Police and bystanders won't intervene.

Both fighters are not bloodlusted but take the fight seriously. Who wins?


r/whowouldwin 2d ago

Challenge What's the strongest fictional Verse composite Mankind can solo?

2 Upvotes

This being is a composite of all of the best feats and strengths of humanity. Capable of lifting up to 6,270 pounds (with extreme difficulty) while also having the skills and punching force of the best boxer to ever exist, likely over 1800 PSI (I could not find a reliable statistic for the strongest recorded human punch, so I just went with Mike Tyson). Composite Human would be able to run 27MPH and can run 350 miles without stopping. They would obviously match the most intelligent human to ever exist and have all knowledge that humans have ever known.

Composite Human would have all of the best equipment: Nukes, LRADs that can blow out eardrums, chemical weapons, etc

Let's just assume that Composite Human spawns into the verse in a big bunker with all of the systems needed to use all relevant equipment. With all of this, what is the strongest verse Composite Man can beat?

(My guess is that Composite Mankind would struggle hard to beat any verse that scales above Large Island Level)


r/whowouldwin 2d ago

Battle Weakest character that can overcome Doomsday's gimmick of resistance?

5 Upvotes

One of Doomsday's gimmicks that pretty much every version has, is that once he's killed and comes back, he can't be killed the same way twice.

Like in the show Superman and Lois, I remember Superman saying that he killed Doomsday multiple times but that the monster just kept coming back.

I don't know how he's beaten in the comics, but who's the weakest character that could actually put down Doomsday despite his gimmick?


r/whowouldwin 2d ago

Challenge Can Jack Slash (Worm) convince these villains to join the Slaughterhouse Nine?

8 Upvotes

It's time for Jack Slash to test his charisma and intelligence by attempting to recruit several fictional villains into the Slaughterhouse Nine. Obviously, Jack can't use his Broadcast ability as none of the villains listed are Parahumans. He has to rely entirely on manipulation and his charisma to succeed. Of course, Jack will be fully in-character. All scenarios take place in the Wormverse.

Which of these villains do you think Jack successfully convinces to join and which do you think would decline and or try to kill him? Respect threads or wiki pages for the villains will be linked below.


  • Villain 1: The Caligula Demon (Caligula Comics). Jack encounters Caligula on a good day for the demon, meaning that he'll be willing to hear Jack out instead of immediately trying to kill or "dominate" him. He will still act in-character, though. Jack has a basic grasp of Caligula's goals and desires to help him convince the demon to join the Nine.
  • Villain 2: Homelander (The Boys, Amazon). Jack encounters current season Homelander from Amazon's version of The Boys. Homelander will be in a relatively decent mood and will be willing to hear what Jack has to say. Like with the previous villain, Jack has a basic understanding of Homelander's goal/desires.
  • Villain 3: War Devil (Chainsaw Man). Jack encounters current Yoru as of CSM Part 2. Like the other villains, she'll be willing to hear him out but of course will act in-character. Jack has a basic understanding of her plan to create endless war.
  • Villain 4: Adam Smasher (Cyberpunk). Jack encounters Adam Smasher, specifically the younger Adam from Cyberpunk 2020. Adam will be willing to hear Jack out and Jack knows of Adam's love of carnage, bloodshed and his hatred of humanity.
  • Villain 5/Final: Kenjaku (Jujutsu Kaisen). Jack encounters Kenjaku, specifically early manga/season Kenjaku before he's able to fully put his plans into motion. Kenjaku will be willing to hear Jack out and Jack has some knowledge of his desire to force the next step in human evolution.

r/whowouldwin 2d ago

Battle Level 30 Wizard(3.5e) Vs One Piece Verse

2 Upvotes

One day a level 30 DnD Wizard is dropped into the one piece Verse he decides to destroy it as a challenge meanwhile the characters fight back

Level 30 optimized cheesy wizard

No pun Pun

Dead characters are back

Who wins?


r/whowouldwin 2d ago

Battle Who would win in a fight between current manga goku vs mcu thanos with half the infinity stones

0 Upvotes

You choose which stones he gets


r/whowouldwin 2d ago

Battle 50,000 poor children with ak-47’s or the germans on d-day

0 Upvotes

50k poor children with average firearm training armed with ak-47s and two extra magazines and a mk 2 grenade or the germans on d-day?


r/whowouldwin 2d ago

Battle Batman beyond vs Taskmaster

3 Upvotes

Batman beyond(Terry Mcginnis) vs Taskmaster. I already know that batman beat taskmaster during a crossover so can his successor from the future do the same?


r/whowouldwin 2d ago

Battle Thragg sees the Empire as an obstacle to Viltrumite rule, so he decides to destroy it's biggest threat, the Death Star. Can the Empire stop him?

44 Upvotes

The Death Star sees Thragg charging at it.

How can they possibly win?

Round 1: They are taken by surprise.

Round 2: They have 10 minutes to prepare.

Round 3: They have 30 minutes to prepare.

Round 4: They have 1 day to prepare.

Preferably canon Empire.

Don't say "X stomps", explain why.


r/whowouldwin 2d ago

Battle John Walker vs Horror Big 3

4 Upvotes

MCU Walker. Canon movie versions for Horror

First is Michael Myers

Second is Jason

Third is Freddy in his world, but John is well informed on how things work there


r/whowouldwin 2d ago

Battle Mr Krabs (SpongeBob) vs Scrooge McDuck (DuckTales)

3 Upvotes

Scrooge McDuck is walking around one day and drops a quarter. But before he can pick it up, a certain red crustaceous cheapstake takes it.

Scrooge: "Excuse me, but that's my quarter you're taking. Give it back!!!"

Mr Krabs: "Was, you dropped it. Finder's keepers!!!"

And a battle begins In this of battle very greedy very old franchise owners (who are nevertheless opposites) who cakes the coin?

Composite for both.

Note: Mr Krabs doesn't need water here.

Also, to make this fight more fair, SpongeBob's high-end feats are ignored.


r/whowouldwin 2d ago

Battle Issei Hyoudou (DxD) vs Tatsumi (Akame) vs Basara Toujou (Shinmai)

2 Upvotes

Context: Issei, Tatsumi, Basara are transported into a massive arena in order to fight to know who is the strongest.

Scenario 1: no foreknowledge.

Scenario 2: with foreknowledge.

Round 1: Issei (Anime) vs Tatsumi (Anime) vs Basara (Anime).

Round 2: Issei (Manga) vs Tatsumi (Manga) vs Basara (Manga).

Round 3: Issei (Light Novels) vs Tatsumi (Manga) vs Basara (Light Novels).

  • Rules:

  • All act in-characters.

  • They all start in base.

  • Victory only by ko.


r/whowouldwin 2d ago

Battle Felix the cat vs Jake the dog

2 Upvotes

Both characters are at peak abilities. They are fighting in a jungle. Both are bloodlusted but don't know anything about the other character.


r/whowouldwin 2d ago

Battle Jason Bourne vs Agent 47 Vs John Wick vs Dutch vs James Bond vs John McClane vs Rambo

18 Upvotes

This battle will take place on an NFL-sized field with barriers to hide behind. Each character will have access to guns, melee weapons, and hand-to-hand combat. Rocket launchers and miniguns will not be allowed.


r/whowouldwin 2d ago

Battle US Marines (SAAB) vs US Colonial Marines (Aliens) vs UNSC Marines (Halo) vs EA Marines (B5)

3 Upvotes

Ground infantry combat only (So no fighters or tanks!).

Who has the better doctrine in urban/desert/jungle warfare? Best in close combat?

Who has the best small arms?


r/whowouldwin 2d ago

Battle All Might (MHA) vs Sengoku (One Piece)

3 Upvotes

Battle takes place in Enies Lobby

Who wins?