r/wrestling • u/emaxwell14141414 • 10h ago
Why are grapplers from the Caucasus currently having an easier time transitioning to MMA than American grapplers?
Granted, it's not the largest of sample sizes, but there's now Ilia Topuria, Merab Dvalishvili, Islam Makhachev, Magomed Ankalaev and now Khamzat Chimaev who've made it to the pinnacle. For the US, there's Nick Piccininni who wasn't able to make it past the contender series and Bo Nickal and Aaron Pico who both have recently lost in devasting fashion. Chimaev and Topuria would've just shredded the opponents they faced. And while Nickal and Pico to be sure weren't at the level of Burroughs, Snyder or Taylor, they were clearly world level competitors in wrestling. And they and numerous others have faltered or likely will; NCAA champ Jordan Oliver isn't looking like he has much of anything for the UFC"s top 5 FWs.
So with grapplers from the US and grapplers from the Caucasus at similar levels, the Caucasus grapplers seem to be leaving US grapplers in the dust. And even going from Nickal and Pico to, say the level of Aaron Brooks or Spencer Lee doesn't seem like it would help. In fact, beyond a certain level, with MMA being what it is, amateur wrestlers might struggle even more to make the transition.
Is it because Caucasus wrestlers are also cross raining at an early age and have better game plans for transitioning from grappling to the complete MMA game? And US grapplers by contrast are still suck years past? Or other factors?